Case Files

Filter by Tag

Cindy Fine phone records

Investigators obtained Cindy's cell phone call records for days when certain people were interviewed.

John Reagle interview #2

The detectives asked Johnny to come in to talk about recent forensic findings.

Additional forensics

The lab provided findings on recently collected evidence in the Fine investigation. Additional analyses are ongoing.

Alibi check

Investigators summarized the alibis for persons of interest and whether those alibis could be corroborated.

JoAnna Laughlin interview #2

The detectives asked JoAnna if she could identify the man in the dark SUV from a photo array.

Carl Fine interview #3

The detectives tried again to get more information from Andy Fine's half-brother.

Fine phone records

Investigators obtained call records for the days surrounding Andy's disappearance and the discovery of his body.

Dudley Brinkman interview #2

The detectives asked Dudley to come in and clear up some unanswered questions.

Cindy Fine interview #3

The detectives asked the victim's wife once again if she wanted to change her story.

Dooley residence search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search the residence of Eddie Dooley.

Reagle residence search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search the residence of John Reagle.

Brinkman residence search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search the residence of Dudley Brinkman.

Laughlin Auto Body search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search Laughlin Automotive & Body Shop.

Laughlin residence search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search the residence of Chas Laughlin.

Carl Fine residence search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search the residence of Carl Fine.

Dykman residence search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search the residence of Bill and Robyn Dykman.

Fine residence search #2

The detectives obtained a warrant to search the Fines' apartment again for new evidence.

JoAnna Laughlin interview

The detectives talked to Chas Laughlin's wife about his activities the weekend Andy was killed.

Updated Places of Interest

Investigators added newly relevant locations to the map for the Andrew Fine investigation.

Gideon Horner interview

The detectives talked to the minister at Cindy Fine's church about Cindy and her marriage.

Gideon Horner bio

Gideon Horner is the minister at Trinity Church in Oxford

DNA profile viewer

Compare the suspects' DNA profiles with DNA profiles from the evidence collected.

Martha Brinkman interview

The detectives talked to Dudley's mother about his activities the weekend Andy Fine was killed.

Follow-up forensics

The lab provided updated findings on evidence in the Fine investigation. Additional analyses are ongoing.

Huddle House canvass

Investigators spoke to restaurant employees and patrons who were there the night of August 1.

Carl Fine interview #2

Detectives Beckwith and Magee tried to talk to Andy's brother again. It didn't go well.

Fine vehicle search warrant

The detectives obtained a warrant to search the vehicle registered to Andrew and Cynthia Fine.

SUV lineup

Witnesses who saw a dark SUV were asked if they could identify the vehicle from a photo array.

SUV witness canvass

Investigators asked witnesses who saw a dark SUV to try to identify it from a photo array.

Dykman biological sample warrants

The detectives obtained additional warrants to collect blood and hair samples from the Dykmans.

Insurance investigator's letter

A private investigator contacted detectives seeking information on the Andrew Fine homicide investigation.

Bill Dykman interview

Detectives Beckwith and Magee talked with Cindy's brother-in-law about Robyn, Cindy, and Andy.

Bill Dykman bio

Bill is married to Cindy Fine's younger sister.

Robyn Dykman interview

Detectives Beckwith and Magee asked Robyn about Cindy and her relationship with Andy.

Robyn Dykman bio

Robyn has always been her sister's closest ally, even when she disagrees with Cindy's choices.

Preliminary forensics

The lab provided preliminary findings on evidence in the Fine homicide investigation. Additional analyses are ongoing.

Eddie Dooley interview #2

The detectives asked Eddie again about what happened at Duffy's the night of August 1.

Theft arrest report

A suspect has been arrested on charges related to the Andrew Fine homicide investigation.

Eddie Dooley criminal history

YCSD investigators ran a routine criminal background check on Eddie Dooley.

Eddie Dooley search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search Eddie Dooley's residence and vehicle.

Chas Laughlin interview #2

Detectives Beckwith and Magee spoke to Andy's employer again to try to clear up some discrepancies.

Cindy Fine interview #2

The detectives talked to the victim's wife again to clarify information they'd heard from other witnesses.

Coroner's report - body

Preliminary report on the autopsy of Andrew Fine. Additional analyses are ongoing.

Eddie Dooley interview

The detectives spoke to Eddie about his interaction with the Fines at Duffy's on August 1st.

Eddie Dooley bio

Eddie's past is littered with petty crimes, but he has no convictions for anything serious.

Blood & hair sample warrants

The detectives obtained warrants to collect biological samples from multiple persons of interest.

Dudley Brinkman interview

The detectives asked Dudley about his encounters with the Fines at Duffy's on August 1.

Dudley Brinkman bio

Dudley knew both Andy and Cindy in high school, one better than the other.

Duffy's employee canvass

Investigators spoke to Duffy's Bar & Grill employees about Andy Fine and John Reagle.

Load more No more items

Ready to solve another case?

Drop Dead Gorgeous

Barbara was favored to win the pageant. Instead, she was brutally murdered.

Investigate the Case
Perfect Aim

When Frederick left church, it wasn't his guardian angel who was watching.

Investigate the Case
Karma Kills

Personal assistant Lee found her boss, literary agent Victor Jennings, dead in a pool of blood in his kitchen.

Investigate the Case
Killer Headache

Diane Coates suddenly collapsed at a conference reception and was declared dead at the hospital.

Investigate the Case
The Last Word

A teenager found a woman shot to death on the side of the road.

Investigate the Case
Blood Bane

Local children happened upon an eerie vandalism scene in a wooded area.

Investigate the Case
Terminal Care

Orderly Jerry Shaw was found dead behind the nursing home where he worked.

Investigate the Case