Intoxicated man arrested

An intoxicated man was arrested at a local bar in possession of a severed human hand.

Photos of alleged human hand

The alleged human hand was photographed and logged as evidence.

Warning: Images may be disturbing for some viewers.

Farmer arrested brandishing hand

The Crime Beat reports: Farmer arrested in possession of alleged severed human hand.

John Reagle bio

A longtime Yoknapatawphan, Johnny is known as a likable guy when he isn't drinking.

John Reagle interview

After Johnny sobered up overnight in jail, the detectives talked to him at the YCSD.

Body found incident report

Johnny Reagle showed the detectives the location on his farm where he dug up the hand.

Body found on area farm

The Crime Beat reports: The body's possible connection to the severed hand is undetermined.

Body location map

Investigators created a map of the location where a body was found on Johnny Reagle's farm.

Andrew Fine missing report

Investigators identified a potentially relevant missing person report filed on July 7th.

Officer Wilkins interview

A fellow YCSD officer contacted the detectives with potential information regarding missing person Andrew Fine.

YCSD seeks witnesses

The Crime Beat reports: The YCSD is seeking the public's help in locating a missing person.

Coroner's report - hand

The coroner's office sent the detectives a preliminary report on the hand. Additional analyses are ongoing.

Andrew Fine bio

When he left the Navy, Andy came home to Oxford, married, and worked as a mechanic.

Archive: Andrew Fine interview

The detectives learned that Andrew Fine had been interviewed in connection with another YCSD investigation.

Cindy Fine bio

Cindy grew up in Oxford and married Andy Fine, a boy she'd known since childhood

Cindy Fine interview

The detectives spoke to Andy Fine's wife to get more information about his life and disappearance.

Farmhouse search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search a house on Reagle Farm Road.

Farmhouse evidence map

Investigators mapped the locations where evidence was found in the Reagle Farm Road farmhouse.

Body identified

The Crime Beat reports: Authorities ID the body found on Reagle Farm Road.

News video

The local news reports live from the crime scene.

Lisa Holman bio

Lisa grew up in Baton Rouge and moved to Oxford with a boyfriend

Lisa Holman interview

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy spoke to Johnny Reagle's ex-girlfriend about Johnny and about Andy Fine.

James Thurston interview

The detectives spoke to the resident manager at Oxford Ridge Apartments, where the Fines live.

Lester Waterson interview

The detectives spoke to the maintenance man at Oxford Ridge apartments where the Fines live.

Cheryl Kline interview

The detectives spoke to the Fines' downstairs neighbor at the Oxford Ridge apartments.

Fine residence search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search the apartment of Andrew and Cynthia Fine.

Chas Laughlin bio

Chas has spent a lifetime living by his own rules.

Chas Laughlin interview

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy spoke to Andy Fine's employer at Laughlin Automotive & Body Shop.

Doug Jordan interview

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy spoke to Doug, one of Andy Fine's co-workers.

Peter "Buck" Buchanan interview

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy talked to Buck, another of Andy Fine's co-workers.

Carl Fine bio

All Andy's life, his older brother tried to spare others from the effects of Andy's temper.

Carl Fine interview

The detectives talked to Andy's half-brother to learn more about Andy and his relationships.

Places of Interest

Investigators mapped locations in Yoknapatawpha County relevant to the Andrew Fine investigation.

Oxford Chalet canvass

Investigators talked to people at the Oxford Chalet apartments, across the street from the Fines' residence.

Duffy's patron canvass

Investigators spoke to Duffy's Bar & Grill customers about Andy Fine and John Reagle.

Duffy's employee canvass

Investigators spoke to Duffy's Bar & Grill employees about Andy Fine and John Reagle.

Dudley Brinkman bio

Dudley knew both Andy and Cindy in high school, one better than the other.

Dudley Brinkman interview

The detectives asked Dudley about his encounters with the Fines at Duffy's on July 3rd.

Blood & hair sample warrants

The detectives obtained warrants to collect biological samples from multiple persons of interest.

Eddie Dooley bio

Eddie's past is littered with petty crimes, but he has no convictions for anything serious.

Eddie Dooley interview

The detectives spoke to Eddie about his interaction with the Fines at Duffy's on July 3rd.

Coroner's report - body

Preliminary report on the autopsy of Andrew Fine. Additional analyses are ongoing.

Cindy Fine interview #2

The detectives talked to the victim's wife again to clarify information they'd heard from other witnesses.

Chas Laughlin interview #2

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy spoke to Andy's employer again to try to clear up some discrepancies.

Eddie Dooley search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search Eddie Dooley's residence and vehicle.

Eddie Dooley criminal history

YCSD investigators ran a routine criminal background check on Eddie Dooley.

Theft arrest report

A suspect has been arrested on charges related to the Andrew Fine homicide investigation.

Eddie Dooley interview #2

The detectives asked Eddie again about what happened at Duffy's the night of July 3rd.

Preliminary forensics

The lab provided preliminary findings on evidence in the Fine homicide investigation. Additional analyses are ongoing.

Login

Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates

Contact

Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries: store@crimescene.com

For technical assistance: support@crimescene.com

Go to top