Seal of Yoknapatawpha County with the label 'Incident Report'

Incident report

Emergency Services received a 911 call reporting an unresponsive male at a local church.

Portion of a drawing of the crime scene showing the body's location

Crime scene illustration

Investigators put together an informal drawing of the crime scene.

Unsmiling woman with dark hair in an updo

Cheryl Harris interview

Detective Armstrong spoke to the 911 caller.

Unsmiling woman with long blonde hair

Angie Jennings interview

Detective Murphy talked to the other woman at the scene.

Man with long blond hair and brown mustache and goatee

Jeremy Willis interview

The detectives asked the third witness at the scene what he saw.

Arrow, pincushion and spools of thread with a stained glass window in the background

Canvass – Sewcial Compassion attendees

Did anyone see or hear anything unusual at the church that night?

Seal of Yoknapatawpha County with the label 'Evidence Inventory'

Crime scene inventory

CSU submitted a preliminary inventory of evidence collected at the crime scene.

Excerpt of a flyer for a charity sewing event

Sewcial Compassion flyer

CSU collected a copy of the Sewcial Compassion event flyer.

Man singing in an empty choral rehearsal room

Teacher slain at local church

The Crime Beat reports: Man exiting church struck with arrow.

Man with receding gray hair and gray mustache and goatee

Frederick Miller bio

Frederick was known as a demanding biology teacher, archery coach, and choir director.

Solemn woman with long dark hair and bangs

Caroline Miller bio

To escape her domineering father, Caroline fled to a midwestern college, where she met Frederick.

Solemn woman with long dark hair and bangs

Caroline Miller interview

Detective Murphy spoke to the victim's wife at the family home.

Teen girl with long dark hair

Lizzie Miller bio

Confident and headstrong, Lizzie is friendly with other teens across all social groups.

Teen girl with long dark hair

Lizzie Miller interview

Detective Armstrong spoke to the victim's daughter at the family home.

Hand holding a pen, signing a Consent to Search form

Miller consent search

Caroline Miller gave the detectives permission to search for evidence in their residence.

Residences, a cluster of mailboxes, and an arrow

Canvass – Miller neighbors

YCSD investigators spoke to Frederick's neighbors to determine whether they saw or heard anything unusual.

Man with reddish-brown hair in a sporting goods store

Lyle Nelson interview

Detective Murphy consulted a local archery expert to get more information about the murder weapon.

Smiling woman with short gray hair

Donna Palmer bio

Donna's faithful service has been essential to the church's growth

Smiling woman with short gray hair

Donna Palmer interview

The detectives talked to the secretary at Faith and Glory Community Church.

Man with light brown hair, graying at the temples

Nathaniel Huggins bio

Nathaniel is no stranger to controversy over his music selections for the church.

Man with light brown hair, graying at the temples

Nathaniel Huggins interview

Detective Armstrong talked with the church choir director about his relationship with Frederick.

apple, stack of books, teacher's mug and arrow in front of a chalkboard

Canvass – victim's co-workers

Investigators spoke to Frederick Miller's co-workers at Yoknapatawpha High School.

Piano keyboard, musical score, and an arrow in front of a stained glass window

Canvass – church choir members

Investigators spoke to members of the Faith and Glory Community Church choir.

Woman with long dark hair and bangs in front of a manila folder stamped 'Alibi'

Alibi check – Caroline Miller

YCSD investigators spoke to witnesses to see if they could corroborate Caroline Miller's alibi.

Teen girl with long dark hair in front of a manila folder stamped 'Alibi'

Alibi check – Lizzie Miller

YCSD investigators spoke to witnesses to see if they could corroborate Lizzie Miller's alibi.

Visit our online store shop.crimescene.com

Spinning loader

Login

Contact

Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries: store@crimescene.com

For technical assistance: support@crimescene.com

Get Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.

Please enable the javascript to submit this form

X