The detectives wanted Carl's response to new information since their last talk

Wednesday, March 13, 2019 – 2:00 p.m.

Carl Asher was Victor Jennings' friend and employee.

Detectives Murphy and Parker re-interviewed him at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department.

Participants:

  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Detective E. Parker
  • Carl Asher

Detective Parker: Please state your name and address before we begin.

Carl Asher: Carlton Asher, 122 Caroline Circle, Oxford.

Detective Parker: Thank you for coming in. After the way our last meeting ended, we thought we might have a problem getting you to cooperate further.

Carl Asher: My bad. I tend to overreact from time to time.

Detective Murphy: Let's start fresh. Have you thought of anything that might help us in our investigation?

Carl Asher: Sure haven't.

Detective Parker: All right. Is there any member of the Jennings family that you think would want Victor dead?

Carl Asher: Why would you ask that? You think one of them killed him?

Detective Parker: I'm just interested in your impression of them.

Carl Asher: Sure you are. Brad thought Victor was the best thing since canned salmon. Little Ray couldn't fight his way out of a wet paper bag. And Margaret? Nah, he was her son, and no matter how much she disliked him, a part of her still loved him.

Detective Parker: So you don't think any of them could've killed him?

Carl Asher: Isn't that what I just said?

Detective Murphy: Please, Carl, let's keep it civil. We're just trying to find some answers.

Carl Asher: I don't have the answers. I don't know who killed him. It sure wasn't me!

Detective Parker: When did you last see Victor alive?

Carl Asher: I don't remember. A day or two before he died maybe?

Detective Murphy: Are you sure you didn't see him the day he died?

Carl Asher: I'm not sure. I don't remember. I might have, I guess.

Detective Parker: Someone told us you were there that day, having coffee in the room Victor was killed a few hours later. Remember now?

Carl Asher: Uh, yeah, I do. My days seem to run together sometimes. I think I was there that morning. Vic's lawyer was there also.

Detective Parker: Did you go into Victor's office that day?

Carl Asher: No.

Detective Parker: Are you sure? I know how your days seem to run together.

Carl Asher: Yeah. I'm sure.

Detective Parker: When was the last time you were in his office?

Carl Asher: Man, I don't know. Who cares?

Detective Murphy: How about this? We understand Victor kept a variety of knickknacks on the credenza in his office. Is that true?

Carl Asher: Are you talking about those dumbass executive toys?

Detective Murphy: Maybe. Do you remember what any of the toys were?

Carl Asher: I don't know. A Slinky, some pendulum thing, that goddamn applause button.

Detective Murphy: Anything else?

Carl Asher: Yeah, but that's all I remember. I don't play with toys.

Detective Murphy: Did you notice if any of those things were not on the credenza anymore the last time you were in his office?

Carl Asher: No.

Detective Murphy: No, they were all still there?

Carl Asher: No, I didn't notice.

Detective Parker: What time did you leave Victor's house on the 9th?

Carl Asher: Shoot, I don't know the exact time. Like you said, my days run together. How in the hell could I give you a time?

Detective Parker: How about a general time, Carl? Can you do that?

Carl Asher: It was a few minutes after the lawyer got there. Vic needed privacy to talk to him and for what he was doing later.

Detective Murphy: What was he doing later?

Carl Asher: He was expecting company.

Detective Parker: Who?

Carl Asher: I believe it was a lady, more or less.

Detective Murphy: More or less?

Carl Asher: Some of his women were more ladylike than others.

Detective Murphy: Did he say anything specific about this company he was expecting?

Carl Asher: I wouldn't repeat what he said to a fine lady such as yourself.

Detective Murphy: That's very gallant of you. Did you by any chance have an accident while you were there that day? Bad paper cut or anything like that?

Carl Asher: Yeah, actually. I broke a coffee cup and cut myself picking up the pieces. So what?

Detective Murphy: There was a lot of blood in the kitchen. I just wanted to know if any of it might be yours.

Carl Asher: I don't think so.

Detective Parker: You've got some experience with … let's call it self-defense. Do you think the killer was injured when he or she killed Victor?

Carl Asher: Are you still trying to pin this on me? How many times do I have to tell you I didn't kill him?

Detective Parker: I don't know. Just something about you makes me want to keep asking.

Carl Asher: C'mon. What about that Kyle Colby kid? He came after Victor with a baseball bat. Maybe he came back with a knife.

Detective Murphy: Right now we're talking about you, not Kyle Colby.

Carl Asher: Don't forget that fancy pants Hawke either. Victor was going to expose his dirty little secret. Hawke certainly didn't want that.

Detective Parker: Interesting. What did you do after you left Victor's house on the 9th?

Carl Asher: I went to get something to eat. Then I ran a few errands, went home, and watched some TV.

Detective Murphy: What programs did you watch?

Carl Asher: I don't remember. No, wait. I was watching basketball, Ole Miss and Missouri. Good game.

Detective Parker: One more time, Carl. Did you kill Victor Jennings?

Carl Asher: I told you no, bitch. How many times you do you want me to say it?

Detective Parker: That's about enough of you for today, Carl. Go. We'll be in touch.

Interview ended – 2:33 p.m.

 

Comments (0)

There are no comments posted here yet
Tell your friends about Crime Scene

Need assistance?

Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates

Contact

Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries: store@crimescene.com

For technical assistance: support@crimescene.com

Go to top