The detectives talked to Kyle about his reaction to what Victor allegedly did to Kristin

Wednesday, March 13, 2019 – 3:37 p.m.

Kyle Colby is Kristin Colby's older brother.

Detectives Murphy and Parker interviewed him at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department.


  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Detective E. Parker
  • Kyle Colby

Detective Murphy: Come in, and pull up that chair.

Kyle Colby: Gee, thanks. I just love coming here and talking to the cops.

Detective Parker: State your name and address for the record.

Kyle Colby: Yes, ma'am. My name is Kyle Colby. My address is 1006 Jackson Avenue.

Detective Murphy: We're happy you changed your mind about coming in.

Kyle Colby: I'm not here because I want to be.

Detective Murphy: Well, thanks for coming in just the same Now, tell us what you know about Victor Jennings.

Kyle Colby: I know the same thing you do. He beat my sister up. I'd like to shake the hand of whoever got rid of him.

Detective Murphy: Who is your sister? We have to have that for the record.

Kyle Colby: Why do you cops always act like you don't know things when you do? You know who she is. Kristin Colby.

Detective Murphy: Thank you. Sounds like you didn't care much for Mr. Jennings. Did you ever speak to him?

Kyle Colby: I only went to his house once. His bullet catcher met me at the door and told me Jennings wasn't available. I know he was there. He was just too much of a chicken to face me.

Detective Parker: Bullet catcher? Seems like Jennings should've had a knife catcher if he wanted to stop you.

Kyle Colby: What? Is that why you made me come here? To lay that on me? I wasn't anywhere near there when that ass bought it.

Detective Murphy: Where were you?

Kyle Colby: I don't remember, but I know I wasn't there. It was a Saturday, right? I work Saturdays down at the garage. After work, we play poker, drink some booze, just fool around. I got plenty of witnesses.

Detective Parker: That sounds like a really exciting Saturday night.

Kyle Colby: Oh, yeah? What do you do? Sit at home watching Twilight movies?

Detective Parker: Yes, exactly.

Detective Murphy: Kyle, we know you had a baseball bat with you when you went to see Victor Jennings. A handy guy like you must carry a knife too.

Kyle Colby: Okay, so I went there with a bat. I didn't even get to see him, I told you. I didn't have my knife on me. And that wasn't even the same day he was offed.

Detective Murphy: What day was it?

Kyle Colby: How the hell should I know? Back in January.

Detective Parker: And what? You just let it go after that? You never went back to try again?

Kyle Colby: Talk to the muscle man with all the tattoos. He knows I never so much as got a glimpse of Jennings that day or any other day.

Detective Parker: What were you planning to do with that bat if you had seen Jennings?

Kyle Colby: What do you think? You know what he did to my sister?

Detective Parker: So he pushed her around a little bit. Does that mean he deserves to get beaten up by a gearhead with a bat?

Kyle Colby: Pushed her around? What the hell kind of cop are you? He tried to rape my sister!

Detective Parker: It couldn't have been that bad since she didn't even bother to report it.

Kyle Colby: You stupid bitch! You come over here and say that to my face. I'll show you what bad is.

Detective Murphy: That's some temper you've got, Kyle. Are you sure you never had it out with Victor Jennings?

Kyle Colby: Oh, you bitches. Yes, you got me. I have a temper. But I didn't kill that asshole. Now if you're done jerking me around, I gotta get back to work.

Detective Murphy: All right. You can go. But stay available, Kyle. Don't make us have to chase you down again.

Kyle Colby: I hope I never see either one of you again.

Detective Parker: Have a nice day.

Interview ended – 4:04 p.m.

Comments (0)

There are no comments posted here yet
Tell your friends about Crime Scene


Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates


Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries:

For technical assistance:

Go to top