Smiling woman with short dark hair

Wednesday, January 15, 2020 – 11:12 a.m.

Sylvia Powell is a registered nurse at the Yoknapatawpha Acres nursing home, where Jerry Shaw worked.

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy re-interviewed her at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department.


  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Sylvia Powell

Detective Murphy: Thank you for coming in. State your name and address for the record.

Sylvia Powell: My name is Sylvia Powell, and I live at 3010 Hillmont Drive, in Oxford.

Detective Murphy: This isn't official yet, Sylvia, but we have reason to believe that Jerry Shaw was murdered. It wasn't an accident.

Sylvia Powell: I heard people talking about that, but I thought it was just ugly gossip. Why would anyone want to kill him? I know he could be a jerk at times, but that's not any reason to kill someone.

Detective Murphy: The last time we talked, you didn't get a chance to tell us about anyone who might have a grudge against Jerry. Can you think of anybody?

Sylvia Powell: Jerry owed Matt Hooper a lot of money from gambling. Matt was pretty mad about that.

Detective Murphy: Do you know why he didn't pay Matt?

Sylvia Powell: Jerry told me he couldn't pay Matt because he spent the money on another bet hoping he would double it, but he lost it all. I told Jerry he needed to stop gambling because he just kept losing, but he wouldn't.

Detective Murphy: How do you know Matt was mad?

Sylvia Powell: The day Jerry died, I saw him with Matt in the hallway. They were arguing, and Matt threatened Jerry. I thought he was going to punch him, but he walked off.

Detective Murphy: How did Matt threaten him?

Sylvia Powell: He called Jerry a few nasty names and said he would get even. He said Jerry would be sorry for ever crossing him.

Detective Armstrong: Ms. Powell, Jerry sort of crossed you as well.

Sylvia Powell: Sure, I was angry with him, but I didn't want to kill him. I loved him.

Detective Armstrong: We heard that your argument was more than just a spat. The word used to describe you was "outraged." You said he would pay for dumping you.

Sylvia Powell: Maybe in the heat of the moment, I said something like that.

Detective Armstrong: Did you kill Jerry Shaw in the heat of the moment?

Sylvia Powell: Of course, I didn't kill Jerry. I loved him. Maybe I did say those things, but I was angry. After all I had done for him, he treated me like a dog. He told me our relationship never meant a thing to him. He said he was tired of sneaking around to see me, and he was tired of me. It broke my heart, but I would never have harmed him.

Detective Murphy: Here are some tissues, Sylvia. Try and calm yourself.

Sylvia Powell: I'm sorry, Detective, but this is hard. I'm torn between loving him and hating him for the way he treated me. But I swear I didn't kill him. Do I need to get a lawyer?

Detective Murphy: That's up to you, Sylvia. As of now, there are no charges against you. Do you want to continue our discussion or stop now?

Sylvia Powell: We can continue. I have nothing to hide.

Detective Murphy: Can you think of anyone else who might've had a problem with Jerry?

Sylvia Powell: I think I told you before that Richard Landrigan and Jerry were always arguing.

Detective Armstrong: Did Jerry ever tell you what those arguments were about?

Sylvia Powell: He said it was Richard's fault that our jobs suck so much. Oh! I'm sorry. I didn't mean to— that our jobs are so unpleasant.

Detective Armstrong: Why was it Richard's fault?

Sylvia Powell: I don't really know. Jerry said Richard did whatever he wanted to make his own life better, but he wasn't doing enough to make anyone else's life better.

Detective Armstrong: What does that mean?

Sylvia Powell: I don't know.

Detective Armstrong: Whose life did Jerry want Richard to make better?

Sylvia Powell: I think Jerry's.

Detective Armstrong: Not yours? Not the residents?

Sylvia Powell: I don't know. He never said.

Detective Armstrong: Did he say what he wanted from Richard to make his life better?

Sylvia Powell: A raise? Jerry never had enough money.

Detective Armstrong: What do you think Richard was doing that had Jerry so worked up?

Sylvia Powell: I— no, I don't think I should say anything. I don't really know anything, and I don't want to guess.

Detective Murphy: Sylvia, we're trying to find out who killed Jerry. Don't you want to help with that?

Sylvia Powell: Of course I do, but I don't think Richard did it.

Detective Murphy: What makes you say that?

Sylvia Powell: Because Richard… he's not a doer. He doesn't do anything. He sits at his desk and does paperwork and talks on the phone, but he never actually, you know… does anything.

Detective Murphy: So it was something he was doing at his desk that upset Jerry?

Sylvia Powell: Probably.

Detective Murphy: Could it have been related to why Matt was upset with Jerry?

Sylvia Powell: I don't see how.

Detective Murphy: Richard never gambled with them?

Sylvia Powell: I can't imagine Richard gambling. He likes money too much.

Detective Armstrong: Do you know Rose Jenkins?

Sylvia Powell: She's a resident. I don't think she gambles either.

Detective Armstrong: Cute. Did you ever take care of her?

Sylvia Powell: No. She's on the north wing, and I work on the south wing.

Detective Armstrong: You ever hear anything about her?

Sylvia Powell: Like what?

Detective Armstrong: Anything about her condition?

Sylvia Powell: Jerry said she was having a harder time remembering things lately.

Detective Armstrong: That's it?

Sylvia Powell: I think so.

Detective Murphy: Thanks again for coming in, Sylvia. If you think of anything else, please let us know.

Sylvia Powell: I will. I want to find Jerry's killer as much as you do. Goodbye, Detectives.

Interview ended – 11:34 a.m.


Comments (0)

There are no comments posted here yet
Tell your friends about Crime Scene


Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates


Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries:

For technical assistance:

Go to top