The detectives asked Devllin's ex to drop by to answer some more questions

Friday, July 13, 2018 – 1:45 p.m.

The detectives asked Mickie Webster, Home Plate's head waitress and Devlin Beauchamp's ex-girlfriend, to come in for another conversation.

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy re-interviewed her at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department.


  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Mickie Webster

Detective Armstrong: Would you please state your full name and address for the record?

Mickie Webster: Michelle Kathleen Webster, 1011 Benbow Circle, Oxford.

Detective Armstrong: Thanks for coming in again. We have a few more questions we need your help to answer.

Mickie Webster: No problem. Anything I can to do help.

Detective Armstrong: You're the head waitress at Home Plate, right?

Mickie Webster: Yes.

Detective Armstrong: You manage the waitstaff?

Mickie Webster: Well, I wouldn't call myself a manager exactly. More like a coordinator.

Detective Armstrong: Okay. As a part of your job, you know where supplies are kept and so forth?

Mickie Webster: Yes.

Detective Armstrong: Do you know if there are any weapons at the restaurant? Just in case of a burglary or something.

Mickie Webster: Weapons? No, of course not.

Detective Armstrong: Not even a baseball bat or anything?

Mickie Webster: Oh, a baseball bat. I don't think of that as a weapon, but yes, there's one of those under the bar, like you said, just in case.

Detective Armstrong: When we were there, there were two bats under the bar.

Mickie Webster: Really?

Detective Armstrong: Any idea how that could've happened?

Mickie Webster: Maybe someone brought it in before or after practice and stuck it under the bar during their shift, and then forgot about it? I don't know.

Detective Armstrong: And if one of the bats had blood on it?

Mickie Webster: What? That's terrible. Someone must've cut themselves behind the bar or gotten scraped up at practice or something. Still, to put it under the bar like that is … gross.

Detective Armstrong: You never noticed two bats under there?

Mickie Webster: No. How long had there been two?

Detective Armstrong: How long would it take you to notice there was an extra bat?

Mickie Webster: Oh, I don't know. It would depend on how busy we were, I guess.

Detective Murphy: You know, Mickie— do you mind if I call you Mickie?

Mickie Webster: Of course not.

Detective Murphy: Okay, Mickie. Since we've been sitting here, I've been looking at your hair, which looks great by the way, but have you changed it recently?

Mickie Webster: Oh. Well, yes. I got it cut not too long ago.

Detective Murphy: And maybe a little color?

Mickie Webster: Oh, I didn't think it was noticeable, but yes.

Detective Murphy: When did you do it?

Mickie Webster: I don't know. A couple of weeks ago maybe.

Detective Murphy: Maybe a little less? Like right after Devlin passed away?

Mickie Webster: Yeah. When that happened, I just … needed a change.

Detective Murphy: Here. Take a tissue. Do you want to take a moment?

Mickie Webster: No, no. I'm okay.

Detective Armstrong: Remind me. When was the last time you saw Devlin?

Mickie Webster: I guess it was that day at work. The day he….

Detective Armstrong: What did you two talk about?

Mickie Webster: Nothing. Just work stuff, customers' orders and things like that.

Detective Armstrong: When was the last time you two talked about something other than work stuff?

Mickie Webster: I don't know. Maybe a week before he ….

Detective Armstrong: What did you talk about then?

Mickie Webster: I don't know. Just things.

Detective Armstrong: Where did this conversation happen?

Mickie Webster: At his house.

Detective Armstrong: How did you come to be at his house?

Mickie Webster: I dropped by to see how he was doing.

Detective Murphy: To find out if another woman was there?

Mickie Webster: No. Well, maybe.

Detective Armstrong: And was there?

Mickie Webster: No, he was alone.

Detective Armstrong: Did he invite you in?

Mickie Webster: Yes.

Detective Armstrong: And what did the two of you do?

Mickie Webster: We talked.

Detective Armstrong: Did you have sex?

Mickie Webster: What?

Detective Murphy: We're all grownups here, Mickie. Just tell us the truth. No one is judging you.

Mickie Webster: Yes, we did, okay?

Detective Armstrong: But you were still broken up afterward?

Mickie Webster: Yes. Nothing changed. He still wanted what he wanted, and I still wanted what I wanted. We just helped each other feel a little less … lonely for a little while.

Detective Armstrong: What day did this happen?

Mickie Webster: I don't know exactly.

Detective Murphy: Yes, you do.

Mickie Webster: It was the Tuesday before he ….

Detective Armstrong: Did you spend the night?

Mickie Webster: No.

Detective Murphy: Do you know Natalie Posner?

Mickie Webster: Huh? No, I don't think so. Is she a customer?

Detective Murphy: She's someone Devlin knew. You never met her?

Mickie Webster: No, I don't think so.

Detective Armstrong: Why were you lurking outside Devlin's office while he was on the phone?

Mickie Webster: Why was I what? I didn't do that.

Detective Armstrong: That's not what we heard.

Mickie Webster: Let me guess. Kat Dixon again, right? She's never happier than when she's stirring up trouble for me.

Detective Armstrong: So you never eavesdropped on Devlin's phone conversations at work?

Mickie Webster: Why would I do that?

Detective Armstrong: You tell us.

Mickie Webster: Well, I didn't do it, so I can't explain it.

Detective Murphy: Have you ever been to California?

Mickie Webster: I was in San Fransisco for a little while in the late '90s, but I haven't been back since. It was too expensive for me.

Detective Murphy: You never went to southern California? You didn't want to see Hollywood? The Los Angeles area?

Mickie Webster: I thought about it, but like I said, it was expensive, and there were other states I wanted to visit. But I haven't been out west for years. Why does it matter now?

Detective Armstrong: Do you know Jessica Durham?

Mickie Webster: Is she in California?

Detective Armstrong: No.

Mickie Webster: Oh, you mean Jessica Durham from here. Yes, she's a friend of mine.

Detective Armstrong: Did you see her the weekend Devlin was killed?

Mickie Webster: Um … oh, yeah. I saw her on Friday when she borrowed my truck for the weekend.

Detective Armstrong: So you had to hoof it all weekend?

Mickie Webster: No. She let me use her car while she had mine.

Detective Armstrong: Did you drive her car over to Devlin's that Saturday night?

Mickie Webster: No. I was home with a migraine. Didn't I tell you that?

Detective Armstrong: So if someone saw you in Jessica's car outside Devlin's house that night?

Mickie Webster: They must be mistaken. Maybe it was another car like hers? I don't know what to tell you except it wasn't me.

Detective Armstrong: So you went home after you left work and didn't leave until the next day?

Mickie Webster: Well, I stopped by the store on the way home, but other than that, yes. Have you ever had a migraine, Detective? It doesn't make you want to go anywhere or do anything other than lie down with your eyes closed and pray the pain will go away.

Detective Armstrong: You were able to talk on the phone though.

Mickie Webster: For a little while, yes. I thought it might distract me from the pain, but it didn't work.

Detective Armstrong: I see. Do you get migraines often?

Mickie Webster: I don't know what you call often. Maybe a few times a year? I'm not sure. Is there anything else you want to know right now? I need to be getting back to work.

Detective Murphy: Okay, Mickie. Thanks for coming in to talk to us again. We'll be in touch.

Mickie Webster: You're going to want to talk to me again?

Detective Murphy: Is that a problem?

Mickie Webster: No. It's just painful. That's all. I want to help, of course, but I don't like talking about all this.

Detective Murphy: That's understandable, but we appreciate your willingness to help us find Devlin's killer. Thanks again for coming in.

Interview ended – 2:19 p.m.

People in this conversation

Comments (1)

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

She conveniently didn’t remember who Jessica was for a minute...

There are no comments posted here yet
Tell your friends about Crime Scene

Need assistance?

Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates


Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries:

For technical assistance:

Go to top