The Seal of Yoknapatawpha County with the label 'Arrest Report'

Intoxicated man arrested

An intoxicated man was arrested at a local bar in possession of a severed human hand.

Pixelated photo of severed human hand. Warning: Images may be disturbing for some viewers

Photos of alleged human hand

The alleged human hand was photographed and logged as evidence.

Warning: Images may be disturbing for some viewers.

Photo of the Duffy's Bar & Grill entrance with the Oxford Weekly Planet logo in the foreground

Farmer arrested brandishing hand

The Crime Beat reports: Farmer arrested in possession of alleged severed human hand.

Man with long dark hair wearing a straw hat and red shirt

John Reagle bio

A longtime Yoknapatawphan, Johnny is known as a likable guy when he isn't drinking.

Man with long dark hair wearing a straw hat and red shirt

John Reagle interview

After Johnny sobered up overnight in jail, the detectives talked to him at the YCSD.

Seal of Yoknapatawpha County with the label "Incident Report"

Body found incident report

Johnny Reagle showed the detectives the location on his farm where he dug up the hand.

Map showing the location where body was found beside Reagle Farm Road

Body location map

Investigators created a map of the location where a body was found on Johnny Reagle's farm.

A cotton field with crime scene tape in front of it and the Oxford Weekly Planet logo in the foreground

Body found on area farm

The Crime Beat reports: The body's possible connection to the severed hand is undetermined.

Seal of Yoknapatawpha County with the label 'Missing Persons Report'

Andrew Fine missing report

Investigators identified a potentially relevant missing person report filed on July 7th.

Photo of a uniformed police officer from behind to protect his identity

Officer Wilkins interview

A fellow YCSD officer contacted the detectives with potential information regarding missing person Andrew Fine.

Photo of the entrance to the red brick building that houses the Yoknapatawpha County Coroner's Office

Coroner's report - hand

The coroner's office sent the detectives a preliminary report on the hand. Additional analyses are ongoing.

Missing poster for Andy Fine with the Oxford Weekly Planet logo in the foreground

YCSD seeks witnesses

The Crime Beat reports: The YCSD is seeking the public's help in locating a missing person.

Unsmiling man with brown and gray hair wearing a red shirt

Archive: Andrew Fine interview

The detectives learned that Andrew Fine had been interviewed in connection with another YCSD investigation.

Smiling man with brown and gray hair

Andrew Fine bio

When he left the Navy, Andy came home to Oxford, married, and worked as a mechanic.

Woman with short blonde hair wearing a white shirt

Cindy Fine bio

Cindy grew up in Oxford and married Andy Fine, a boy she'd known since childhood

Woman with short blonde hair wearing a white shirt

Cindy Fine interview

The detectives spoke to Andy Fine's wife to get more information about his life and disappearance.

Seal of Yoknapatawpha County with a search warrant label

Farmhouse search

The detectives obtained a warrant to search a house on Reagle Farm Road.

Floor plan of the farmhouse on Reagle Farm Road

Farmhouse evidence map

Investigators mapped the locations where evidence was found in the Reagle Farm Road farmhouse.

Woman holding a microphone with a cotton field in the background and a news chyron in the foreground

News video

The local news reports live from the crime scene.

collage with the severed hand in the upper left, Andrew Fine in the upper right, and the cotton field where his body was found across the bottom and the Oxford Weekly Planet logo in the foreground

Body identified

The Crime Beat reports: Authorities ID the body found on Reagle Farm Road.

Unsmiling woman with short dark hair, wearing a black tank top

Lisa Holman bio

Lisa grew up in Baton Rouge and moved to Oxford with a boyfriend

Unsmiling woman with short dark hair, wearing a black tank top

Lisa Holman interview

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy spoke to Johnny Reagle's ex-girlfriend about Johnny and about Andy Fine.

Man with gray hair and beard, wearing coveralls and standing in front of a rusted antique vehicle

Lester Waterson interview

The detectives spoke to the maintenance man at Oxford Ridge apartments where the Fines live.

Large silver-haired man wearing a plaid shirt and standing in front of a rusted antique vehicle

James Thurston interview

The detectives spoke to the resident manager at Oxford Ridge Apartments, where the Fines live.

Woman with gray hair, wearing a light-colored jacket and black shirt

Cheryl Kline interview

The detectives spoke to the Fines' downstairs neighbor at the Oxford Ridge apartments.

Visit our online store shop.crimescene.com

Spinning loader

Login

Contact

Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries: store@crimescene.com

For technical assistance: support@crimescene.com

Get Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.

Please enable the javascript to submit this form

X