Saturday, December 10, 2011 - 11:00 p.m.

The interview was conducted at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department by Detective's Murphy and Armstrong. The interview was recorded with the witness' knowledge and consent.


  • Detective Ted Armstrong
  • Detective Samantha Murphy
  • Jimmy John Carnes

Detective Armstrong: Take a seat right over there. Let's start off with your name and address.

Jimmy Carnes: My name is Jimmy Carnes, and my trailer is in Lot 66 at the Wheel Estates, on 913 South 18th St.

Detective Armstrong: OK. That's out of the way. What can you tell us about what you saw? Did you know the victim?

Jimmy Carnes: I wish I could tell you who committed this horrible act, but I can't think of anyone that depraved. And no, I didn't know her. She has been by before to use the restroom or buy a Coke or whatever. I never talked to her, though. She always just came in and did what she needed to do without saying much. She never had skates on before, and I thought it was strange that she had them on tonight when I saw her in the restroom. Do you think whoever set up those candles also put the skates on her?

Detective Murphy: That remains to be seen. Tell us what you saw.

Jimmy Carnes: Nothing! I didn't know anything had happened until the lady came up and asked if I would let her in the restroom. She said she really had to go, and she tried to ignore the sign on the door but couldn't, so she said she tried the handle and the door was locked and could I please let her go. I didn't even know the door was locked or what sign she was talking about.

Detective Armstrong: So being a smart young man like you, you went to see what was going on, didn't you?

Jimmy Carnes: That's right. When I saw the Out of Order sign on the door, I was stumped because I hadn't put it there, and I was working alone.

Detective Murphy: And, what happened next?

Jimmy Carnes: I tried to open the door, but the lady was right. It was locked. I had to go back to the office to get the key. The one we always use was missing, so I had to get the other key out of the desk drawer. Then I walked back and opened the door. I called out before I went in just in case someone was there, but no one answered so I went in. That's when I saw her.

Detective Murphy: Go on.

Jimmy Carnes: I thought maybe she had fainted, so I walked towards her and then I saw the blood. Lots of blood. It makes me sick just thinking about it all. It was awful.

Detective Murphy: Did you notice anything else?

Jimmy Carnes: Oh yeah. Candles. All lined up in the shape of a cross and they were burning. It was eerie.

Detective Armstrong: Did you touch anything or pick up anything?

Jimmy Carnes: Gosh, no. I couldn't take my eyes off of her. Her eyes were open and I knew she was dead. The lady that was behind me screamed and ran out the door. I got goose bumps then, and I ran out too.

Detective Armstrong: Think carefully now. Are you sure that's all?

Jimmy Carnes: I can't think of anything else. Oh yeah, I did see some paper on the floor. Maybe a gum wrapper or candy wrapper. That isn't important though, I'm sure.

Detective Armstrong: Everything is important, Jimmy. Who used the restroom last?

Jimmy Carnes: We have a lot of people using the restrooms. I don't remember who was there last. I've been trying to think if there was anything I could have done, something maybe I missed that would have warned me. And then I remembered that I saw some guy walking out of the office earlier tonight. He acted like he was hiding something under his jacket, so I ran in the office to see if anything was stolen, but nothing was gone that I could see. After all this happened tonight, I was thinking maybe that was what he was doing. Taking the sign and the key.

Detective Murphy: What did he look like?

Jimmy Carnes: I never saw his face. And he only saw him for a few seconds. He went around the corner towards the restrooms, and I forgot about him after I realized nothing had been stolen.

Detective Armstrong: Picture him in your mind, Jimmy. Nothing that you can tell us?

Jimmy Carnes: His hair was dark, but I can't remember anything else about him.

Detective Murphy: Thank you, Jimmy. And if you recall anything else‒

Jimmy Carnes: Wait! I did notice that he was whistling. Sounded a little like a song I used to sing in church when I was a little boy. Is that important?

Detective Murphy: Could be. You never know.

Jimmy Carnes: I really need to get back to work now. Can I go?

Detective Murphy: The station is a crime scene. It's going to be closed for at least the rest of the night, but I don't think we have any other questions for right now. You can go. We'll be in touch if we need anything else from you.

End interview: 11:18 p.m.

Tell your friends about Crime Scene

Visit our
forensic detective store

Shop at Crime Scene

Fingerprint Poster

$18 $10

Teachers and CSI fans love this fingerprint matching learning aid that shows what the pros look for to ID prints.

  • Illustrates common fingerprint comparison characteristics
  • 24" by 36"

Free shipping
for orders over $60

Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates


Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries:

For technical assistance:

Go to top