Login

Investigator's note: Any subject whose fingerprints were not already on file was asked to provide them at the time of his or her interview.

Yoknapatawpha County Forensic Laboratory

DATE ANALYSIS PERFORMED:

8/3/2012

Madeline Holland, Ph.D.
555 Jackson Avenue
Oxford, MS 38655
662-281-XXXX (FAX 662-281-XXXX)

Analysis: Fingerprint Analysis

 


Click to enlarge

Print #: 002262-P004

SUMMARY REPORT OF FINGERPRINT ANALYSIS

Case Description:
 Ambrose Garrett Death Investigation

Case #
 002262-15G-2012

Investigative Agency:
 Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department

Investigating Officer(s):
 Det. S. Murphy, Det. T. Armstrong


The following full and partial fingerprints recovered from the crime scene and from evidence items were analyzed for identification with the results shown:

 

002262-01: One (1) clear glass drinking glass, approx. 4" tall and 3" in diameter
Print # Identification
 002262-P001 13 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett R3
 002262-P002 13 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett R2
 002262-P003 12 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett R4
 002262-P004 15 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett R1

002262-02: One (1) clear glass drinking glass, approx. 4" tall and 3" in diameter
Print # Identification
 002262-P005 12 points of similarity to Warren Edwards R3
 002262-P006 11 points of similarity to Warren Edwards R3
 002262-P007 13 points of similarity to Warren Edwards R2

002262-03 through 002262-09: Seven (7) 8-1/2" x 11" papers, copies of the HOA meeting agenda
Print # Identification
 002262-P008 13 points of similarity to Mary Wallace R1
 002262-P009 14 points of similarity to Mary Wallace R2
 002262-P010 9 points of similarity to Julie Arbuckle R3
 002262-P011 10 points of similarity to Mary Wallace R2
 002262-P012 11 points of similarity to Mary Wallace L1
 002262-P013 11 points of similarity to Julie Arbuckle R1

002262-10-001: One (1) men's wallet, black leather (from inside right pocket)
Print # Identification
 002262-P014 12 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett R1
 002262-P015 13 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett L3
 002262-P016 10 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett L1
 002262-P017 11 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett L3

002262-10-003: One (1) stainless steel hip flask, 4-1/6" x 6-1/4" x 1", 12-ounce capacity, empty (from inside left pocket)
Print # Identification
 No fingerprints recovered


002262-10-006: One (1) cellular phone (from left front pocket)
Print # Identification
 002262-P019 10 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett R2
 002262-P020 13 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett R3
 002262-P021 11 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett R1

Surface of the table where the deceased was found
Print # Identification
 002262-P022 12 points of similarity to David McMahan R3
 002262-P023 15 points of similarity to Mary Wallace R3
 002262-P024 13 points of similarity to Mary Wallace R2
 002262-P025 12 points of similarity to Julie Arbuckle R2
 002262-P026 14 points of similarity to Warren Edwards L3
 002262-P027 13 points of similarity to David McMahan R3
 002262-P028 14 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett R2
 002262-P029 12 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett L3
 002262-P030 13 points of similarity to Patrick Tyler R3
 002262-P031 10 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett R3
 002262-P032 17 points of similarity to David McMahan L2
 002262-P033 15 points of similarity to Ambrose Garrett L2
 002262-P034 14 points of similarity to Julie Arbuckle R2
 002262-P035 11 points of similarity to Mary Wallace R3
 002262-P036 11 points of similarity to James Covington R1
 002262-P037 13 points of similarity to Mary Wallace R2

 

People in this conversation

Comments (5)

  1. Elise Cederlund

The drinking glass that contained approx 2" of clear liquid has two fingerprints from Warren Edwards on it. In interview with Edwards, Det Armstrong indicates someone saw him hanging around after the meeting, which Edwards denies. Edwards also...

The drinking glass that contained approx 2" of clear liquid has two fingerprints from Warren Edwards on it. In interview with Edwards, Det Armstrong indicates someone saw him hanging around after the meeting, which Edwards denies. Edwards also volunteers, almost insists, that Garrett was murdered. This interview occurs before the coroner's initial report is released and that information is available to the public...

Read More
  Attachments
Your account does not have privileges to view attachments in the comment
 
  1. Elise Cederlund    Elise Cederlund

Indications: Warren and Garrett haven't been neighborly; far from it. The incident with the late evening hedge trimmer was Garrett goading Warren into confrontation and purposely trying to annoy him. As indicated in the interview with Warren,...

Indications: Warren and Garrett haven't been neighborly; far from it. The incident with the late evening hedge trimmer was Garrett goading Warren into confrontation and purposely trying to annoy him. As indicated in the interview with Warren, Garrett ignored Warren's input at meetings. Warren avoids discussing Garrett's responses to his concerns offered at the meeting, because there were none...

Read More
  Attachments
Your account does not have privileges to view attachments in the comment
 
  1. Elise Cederlund    Elise Cederlund

Opportunity: After everyone had left, Warren remained behind and either shared his own beverage that he brought (filled with isopropyl) or introduced poisioning to Garrett's flask or glass. The flask is wiped clean. The second glass is missing...

Opportunity: After everyone had left, Warren remained behind and either shared his own beverage that he brought (filled with isopropyl) or introduced poisioning to Garrett's flask or glass. The flask is wiped clean. The second glass is missing any thumbprint indicating attempt to wipe clean...

Read More
  Attachments
Your account does not have privileges to view attachments in the comment
 
  1. Elise Cederlund    Elise Cederlund

Theory/Possible motive: Garrett is the father of Eve's (Warren's daughter) unborn child, or at least Warren suspects this. With increasing alcohol abuse and confrontation between these two neighbors, is a motive for murder. End.

  Attachments
Your account does not have privileges to view attachments in the comment
 
  1. melina

It's weird that there were no fingerprint on the flask. So, obviously someone wiped it out.

  Attachments
Your account does not have privileges to view attachments in the comment
 
There are no comments posted here yet

Contact

Crime Scene
3440 N 16th St, Suite #4
Phoenix, AZ 85016
Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280
support@crimescene.com

 

Find us on Google+

Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates

Go to top
JSN Boot template designed by JoomlaShine.com