The detectives asked Emily to come in for some follow-up questions

Monday, October 15, 2018 – 4:30 p.m.

Emily Peyton was a colleague of Kristi Waterson.

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy re-interviewed her at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department.

Participants:

  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Emily Peyton

Detective Murphy: Good afternoon, Ms. Peyeton. How are you today?

Emily Peyton: I'd be better if I knew what all this is about! I told you everything I know the first time you had me in here. What's going on?

Detective Armstrong: Calm down, ma'am. We'll get to that, but first state your name and address for the record, please.

Emily Peyton: This is ridiculous and a waste of my time

Detective Murphy: It'll go a lot faster if you just cooperate, Ms. Peyton. Now, your name and address, please.

Emily Peyton: Oh, all right. Emily Peyton. I live at 120 Faculty Row, but you already have all of that.

Detective Armstrong: Now, Ms. Peyton. You know this is an ongoing investigation into the murder of Kristal Waterson. Our problem is we haven't been able to eliminate you as a suspect. Tell us why it couldn't have been you.

Emily Peyton: It couldn't have been me because I had nothing to do with that woman's death. It's that simple. What do you have that makes you think I was involved?

Detective Murphy: Do you suspect someone in particular or know for sure who did it?

Emily Peyton: Of course I don't know who did it. That's your job. I just know I had nothing to do with that woman's death. Talk to her students. She was much friendlier with them than she was with me.

Detective Murphy: The last time we spoke to you, you said you knew we had evidence against Hunter Nelson, yet we hadn't released any information on that to the media.

Emily Peyton: So?

Detective Armstrong: So how could you know something that only we and Ms. Waterson's killer could know?

Emily Peyton: I didn't know you had anything, and since you released that Nelson kid, you must not have.

Detective Armstrong: But that's not what you said.

Emily Peyton: Look, John and I talked about it. He said you must have had some kind of evidence to get a search warrant on someone like Hunter Nelson because otherwise, you'd make jackasses out of yourselves. Looks like you did anyway.

Detective Murphy: How might Mr. Brewer have known we have evidence?

Emily Peyton: It's Dr. Brewer, and John reads about that stuff, but I can't read his mind. Go ask him yourselves.

Detective Armstrong: Tell me again where you were the night Ms. Waterson was killed.

Emily Peyton: This is ridiculous. I told you once I was with John — John Brewer — all evening, from the time we met at Old Venice until I went home about 2:00 a.m.

Detective Murphy: But you weren't with him on the drive from the restaurant to his home were you?

Emily Peyton: Well, no, but—

Detective Armstrong: And he wasn't there when you arrived.

Emily Peyton: No, but—

Detective Murphy: Where do you suppose he was?

Emily Peyton: If you would give me a chance to get a word in, I'd tell you.

Detective Armstrong: Okay. Tell us.

Emily Peyton: He stopped at the liquor store to get a certain kind of wine I like. He had the bottle in his hand when he arrived. He's very thoughtful that way.

Detective Murphy: And what kind of wine did he buy?

Emily Peyton: I especially like Beringer's White Zinfandel. It's too sweet for his taste, so he gets it just for me.

Detective Armstrong: And where were you during this separation time?

Emily Peyton: I drove directly to his house, and then I waited in my car in his driveway until he arrived. It couldn't have been more than a few minutes.

Detective Murphy: But you don't know if anybody saw you there.

Emily Peyton: No, unless his nosy neighbor was peeking out her window. Why don't you go ask her?

Detective Murphy: Ms. Peyton, did you kill Kristi Waterson?

Emily Peyton: What? Are you crazy? How many times do I have to tell you I had nothing to do with her death? I'll admit I wasn't fond of her, but I certainly didn't wish her dead. … Well, anyway, I didn't kill her.

Detective Murphy: Would there be any reason for us to find evidence that you were in Ms. Waterson's apartment?

Emily Peyton: Of course not because I never was in her apartment. I told you before we weren't exactly buddies, but I had nothing to do with her murder — and I'm leaving now. I've had enough of this nonsense.

Detective Armstrong: Ms. Peyton, you're free to go, of course, but we may be talking with you again.

Emily Peyton: Not without my attorney, you won't. I'm sick of this harassment. Goodbye.

Interview ended – 5:53 p.m.

Comments (0)

There are no comments posted here yet
Tell your friends about Crime Scene

Need assistance?

Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates

Contact

Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries: store@crimescene.com

For technical assistance: support@crimescene.com

Go to top