Smiling blonde young woman in a cheerleading outfit

Jennifer Adams interview #2

Tuesday, July 18, 2023 – 5:17 p.m.

Jennifer Adams is a cheerleader at Yoknapatawpha High School and is the person who found Katy Brown's body.

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy re-interviewed her at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department.


  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Jennifer Adams

Detective Murphy: Thanks for coming in again, Jennifer.

Jennifer Adams: Hi. What's up? I thought we were done.

Detective Murphy: For the record, please state your name and address.

Jennifer Adams: My name is Jennifer Adams, and I live at 228 St. Andrews Circle. Now what?

Detective Murphy: Thank you. So, the last time we talked, you didn't exactly tell the truth, did you, Jennifer?

Jennifer Adams: What do you mean? Of course, I told you the truth.

Detective Murphy: You said you and Katy were the best of friends. That wasn't true, was it?

Jennifer Adams: Sure it was. We liked each other and got along fine.

Detective Murphy: That's not what we've been hearing. Did you have an altercation with Katy at practice recently?

Jennifer Adams: Who told you that? Coach? She just misunderstood. Katy and I weren't really mad at each other.

Detective Murphy: Did you push Katy?

Jennifer Adams: Yes, I did. She was being nasty, and she deserved more than being pushed. I kept myself under control and held back, but she didn't. She slapped me!

Detective Murphy: Why did she do that? Did you do something to her?

Jennifer Adams: No, I just told her that her brother was following the girls and creeping them out, and she lost it and hit me. I just laughed.

Detective Armstrong: She slapped you in front of everyone, and you laughed?

Jennifer Adams: Yeah.

Detective Armstrong: Okay. And there was nothing more to the argument than that? You insulted her brother, and she defended him.

Jennifer Adams: I just told the truth. If she thought it was insulting, that's her problem.

Detective Armstrong: So the fact that Katy was the captain and you weren't didn't have anything to do with it?

Jennifer Adams: Katy didn't deserve to be captain. She wasn't nearly as good as me, and those idiots chose her! How stupid was that?

Detective Armstrong: It sounds like you were angry enough to kill her.

Jennifer Adams: No! I was at the Cheer Up thing anyway. There's no way I could have killed Katy. No way.

Detective Murphy: Are you still a cheerleader?

Jennifer Adams: Haven't you heard? I'm the new captain! All that trouble with Katy is over now, and with me as team captain, we'll show everyone that we're the best!

Detective Armstrong: It sounds like you're glad Katy's dead.

Jennifer Adams: I'm not, either. But I'm happy to be the captain now. I'll show everyone.

Detective Murphy: Last time, we asked you if you knew who could have killed Katy, and you said Sherry Guyton might have done it. Do you still feel that way?

Jennifer Adams: Sure. I still don't trust Sherry.

Detective Murphy: Why?

Jennifer Adams: I just don't.

Detective Murphy: That's not good enough, Jennifer.

Jennifer Adams: What do you want from me? Everyone knows that Sherry has hated Katy ever since she got hurt. What more do you need to know?

Detective Murphy: That might explain why Katy wouldn't trust her, but what does it have to do with you not trusting her?

Jennifer Adams: Look, she goes around talking bad about all the cheerleaders. That's not okay. I mean, it was one thing for her to talk about Katy, but what did the rest of us ever do to her?

Detective Armstrong: Is there anybody else you don't trust, anybody else who might have wanted Katy dead?

Jennifer Adams: I don't understand why you're asking me these questions. Is it because I'm the one who found her? Bad luck doesn't make me an expert.

Detective Murphy: Before Katy was killed and you became the captain, had you acted as her second-in-command, even unofficially?

Jennifer Adams: She respected my opinion.

Detective Murphy: People probably saw that, which is probably why you were made captain so quickly. Did the two of you talk about personal issues?

Jennifer Adams: I wouldn't say that. We weren't friends or anything.

Detective Murphy: I thought you were the best of friends. Isn't that what you told us?

Jennifer Adams: Whatever. We weren't that kind of friends.

Detective Murphy: So she wouldn't have confided in you?

Jennifer Adams: Um, no.

Detective Armstrong: What's it been like working with Ms. Puskus now that you're captain?

Jennifer Adams: Great. She's a wonderful coach.

Detective Armstrong: She must advise you since you're still so new to the job, tell you how Katy would have handled things?

Jennifer Adams: Not at all. In fact, she said I've been doing a great job as captain, especially under these trying circumstances. She said I'll take the team all the way.

Detective Murphy: I just had a thought. Maybe Katy wasn't killed because she was Katy. Maybe she was killed because she was the cheerleading captain. Now that you're captain, have you received any threats?

Jennifer Adams: No. Of course not. Why would anyone want to threaten me?

Detective Murphy: If you do, don't keep them to yourself. Come to us right away if anything unusual happens.

Jennifer Adams: You don't really think I'm in danger, do you?

Detective Murphy: Until we catch whoever killed Katy, we don't know what else he or she might do. Keep your eyes and ears open.

Jennifer Adams: You're freaking me out.

Detective Armstrong: We don't mean to do that, Jennifer, but I'm sure you understand our concern. You'd probably be doing yourself a favor if you thought long and hard about who might have killed Katy.

Jennifer Adams: It's not like I know, and I'm just not telling you.

Detective Armstrong: That's nice to hear, and I hope it's true. If you remember anything that might help us find Katy's killer, you let us know, okay?

Jennifer Adams: I will. Can I go now? You're freaking me out.

Detective Armstrong: You can go. And you take good care, okay?

Jennifer Adams: Oh my god.

Interview ended – 5:38 p.m.


Latent Fingerprint Kit

 $ 44.00

A real print kit, fully stocked with instructions and enough supplies for at least 50 different print lifts.

ForensiKit Subscription Box


$ 44- 54

Explores a different crime scene processing technique each month.

Forensic Science Kit, Missy Hammond Murder

$ 75.00 $ 50.00

Examine the evidence to solve a murder. Dust evidence for prints & test fabric for the presence of blood.

Shop Now



Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries:

For technical assistance:

Get Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.

Please enable the javascript to submit this form