The detectives invited Katy's boyfriend to come in and tell them about her

Monday, September 3, 2018 – 12:30 p.m.

Tim Howorth was Katy Brown's boyfriend.

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy re-interviewed him at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department.


  • Detective Ted Armstrong
  • Detective Samantha Murphy
  • Tim Howorth

Detective Armstrong: Thanks for coming back in, Tim.

Tim Howorth: Anything I can do to help, detectives.

Detective Murphy: For the record, would you state your name and address?

Tim Howorth: My name's Tim Howorth, I live at 221 Cooke Street.

Detective Armstrong: Okay. Just so we’re clear, Tim, you’re here voluntarily, and you can leave anytime you want to. Do you understand?

Tim Howorth: Yeah.

Detective Murphy: Do you recognize this, Tim?

Tim Howorth: Yeah, it looks like her diary.

Detective Armstrong: Whose diary?

Tim Howorth: Katy's.

Detective Murphy: Did you ever read it?

Tim Howorth: No, ma'am, she wouldn't let me. She said it was private.

Detective Armstrong: Katy wrote that she was afraid of you. Any particular reason she would be?

Tim Howorth: Are you saying I killed her?

Detective Murphy: The reason we're here today is so we can get to the bottom of what this means. No one is accusing you of anything.

Tim Howorth: Yeah, right.

Detective Armstrong: Tell us about the night of August 4th.

Tim Howorth: That was Steve's 18th birthday party.

Detective Armstrong: Were you drinking at that party?

Tim Howorth: I had a couple of beers. So what?

Detective Murphy: Does Steve have a last name?

Tim Howorth: I don’t want to get him in trouble.

Detective Murphy: You need someone who can corroborate your story, so we’ll know whether you’re telling us the truth or not.

Tim Howorth: Fine. Steve Robins.

Detective Armstrong: What did you do after the party?

Tim Howorth: Katy texted me and said she was bored after hanging out with her doofus brother all day. She asked me if I wanted to come over and watch a movie, so I said sure.

Detective Armstrong: Katy's parents had no problem with you being over there so late at night?

Tim Howorth: Well, like I said, I was kinda drunk, so I snuck in through the back window. They never knew I was there.

Detective Armstrong: Then what happened?

Tim Howorth: We were trying to pick out a movie, and she's all like "Let's watch Mamma Mia," and I'm like "No, let's watch something good." She got mad, and we argued, and at one point, I grabbed the remote and threw it against the wall. Then I left.

Detective Murphy: Did you touch her or threaten her?

Tim Howorth: No, nothing like that. I was drunk, I didn't want to watch that dumb movie, so I threw the remote. I was just being stupid.

Detective Murphy: Was that the only time you did something that scared her?

Tim Howorth: I guess.

Detective Murphy: She wrote that when you drink you turn into an angry guy she didn’t know and didn’t like.

Tim Howorth: She said that?

Detective Murphy: See right here?

Tim Howorth: Wow. I mean, I knew she got all goody-goody about the drinking, but she never said anything about … that.

Detective Murphy: Has anyone else ever mentioned that you get angry when you drink?

Tim Howorth: I don’t know. Maybe.

Detective Murphy: You should give that some serious thought. Maybe it’s not a good idea for you to be drinking. And that’s aside from the fact that you’re underage and it’s illegal.

Tim Howorth: Yeah, okay.

Detective Murphy: This isn’t a joke, Tim. You need to take this seriously. Your whole future could depend on it.

Tim Howorth: Okay, okay!

Detective Armstrong: A couple weeks after that incident with the movie, Katy wrote that you had been acting strangely.

Tim Howorth: So?

Detective Armstrong: She thought maybe you wanted to break up with her.

Tim Howorth: She did?

Detective Armstrong: Were you looking to get out of your relationship with Katy?

Tim Howorth: Yeah, I guess. I just didn’t know she knew that.

Detective Armstrong: Why did you want to end the relationship?

Tim Howorth: You know, she was nice and all, but her family is weird. Her brother’s a creepy little doofus, always following us around and stuff. It’s like he got mad whenever someone else was around her.

Detective Armstrong: You must be pretty relieved. Breaking up is difficult and painful. Now that she's dead you won't have to go through all—

Tim Howorth: I didn't kill her to break up with her!

Detective Armstrong: Then why did you kill her?

Tim Howorth: What? No, that came out wrong. I didn't kill her at all!

Detective Armstrong: We’d like to believe that, Tim. What does your new girlfriend have to say about it?

Tim Howorth: New girlfriend?

Detective Armstrong: We heard you were seeing someone new.

Tim Howorth: Not that again. Paula and I are just friends. I don’t know why people don’t get that.

Detective Armstrong: Did you kill Katy so you could be with Paula?

Tim Howorth: You’ve lost it. I already told you, I didn’t kill her! You think I’d kill someone just so I wouldn’t have to break up with her? That’s insane. You said earlier I could go whenever I want, so I want to leave now.

Detective Murphy: That’s fine, Tim, but can I ask you one more thing before you go? It doesn’t have anything to do with Katy.

Tim Howorth: What do you want?

Detective Murphy: Do you wear contacts?

Tim Howorth: What?

Detective Murphy: Do you wear contact lenses?

Tim Howorth: Since I was twelve.

Detective Murphy: It would help us out a lot if you could get us a copy of your vision prescription.

Tim Howorth: My prescription?

Detective Murphy: We could get a court order for it, but if you provided it voluntarily, that would help us out a lot.

Tim Howorth: I'll have to find it, but I can email it to you later, I guess.

Detective Murphy: Thank you. We really appreciate it.

Detective Armstrong: Hey Tim, just one last thing.

Tim Howorth: What?

Detective Armstrong: How were you going to do it?

Tim Howorth: Do what?

Detective Armstrong: Break up with Katy.

Tim Howorth: I guess we'll never know.

Interview ended – 1:03 p.m.

Comments (0)

There are no comments posted here yet
Tell your friends about Crime Scene

Need assistance?

Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates


Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries:

For technical assistance:

Go to top