The detectives asked Jennifer to come in again to clear up some conflicting information

Tuesday, August 28, 2018 – 5:17 p.m.

Jennifer Adams is a cheerleader at Yoknapatawpha High School and is the person who found Katy Brown's body.

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy re-interviewed her at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department.


  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Jennifer Adams

Detective Murphy: Thanks for coming in again, Jennifer.

Jennifer Adams: Hi. What's up? I thought we were done.

Detective Murphy: For the record, please state your name and address.

Jennifer Adams: My name is Jennifer Adams, and I live at 228 St. Andrews Circle. Now what?

Detective Murphy: Thank you. So, the last time we talked, you didn't exactly tell the truth, did you, Jennifer?

Jennifer Adams: What do you mean? Of course, I told you the truth.

Detective Murphy: You said that you and Katy were the best of friends. That wasn't true, was it?

Jennifer Adams: Sure it was. We liked each other and got along fine.

Detective Murphy: That's not what we've been hearing. Did you have an altercation with Katy at practice recently?

Jennifer Adams: Who told you that? Coach? She just misunderstood. Katy and I weren't really mad at each other.

Detective Murphy: Did you push Katy?

Jennifer Adams: Yes, I did. She was being nasty, and she deserved more than being pushed. I kept myself under control and held back, but she didn't. She slapped me!

Detective Murphy: Why did she do that? Did you do something to her?

Jennifer Adams: No, I just told her that her brother was following the girls and creeping them out, and she lost it and hit me. I just laughed.

Detective Armstrong: She slapped you in front of everyone, and you laughed?

Jennifer Adams: Yeah.

Detective Armstrong: Okay. And there was nothing more to the argument than that? You insulted her brother, and she defended him.

Jennifer Adams: I just told the truth. If she thought it was insulting, that's her problem.

Detective Armstrong: So the fact that Katy was the captain and you weren't didn't have anything to do with it?

Jennifer Adams: Katy didn't deserve to be captain. She wasn't nearly as good as me, and those idiots chose her! How stupid was that?

Detective Armstrong: It sounds like you were angry enough to kill her.

Jennifer Adams: No! I was at the Cheer Up thing anyway. There's no way I could have killed Katy. No way.

Detective Murphy: Are you still a cheerleader?

Jennifer Adams: Haven't you heard? I'm the new captain! All that trouble with Katy is over now, and with me as team captain, we'll show everyone that we're the best!

Detective Armstrong: It sounds like you're glad Katy's dead.

Jennifer Adams: I'm not, either. But I'm happy to be the captain now. I'll show everyone.

Detective Murphy: Last time, we asked you if you knew who could have killed Katy, and you said Sherry Guyton might have done it. Do you still feel that way?

Jennifer Adams: Sure. I still don't trust Sherry.

Detective Murphy: Why?

Jennifer Adams: I just don't.

Detective Murphy: That's not good enough, Jennifer.

Jennifer Adams: What do you want from me? Everyone knows that Sherry has hated Katy ever since she got hurt. What more do you need to know?

Detective Murphy: That might explain why Katy wouldn't trust her, but what does it have to do with you not trusting her?

Jennifer Adams: Look, she goes around talking bad about all the cheerleaders. That's not okay. I mean, it was one thing for her to talk about Katy, but what did the rest of us ever do to her?

Detective Armstrong: Is there anybody else you don't trust, anybody else who might have wanted Katy dead?

Jennifer Adams: I don't understand why you're asking me these questions. Is it because I'm the one who found her? Bad luck doesn't make me an expert.

Detective Murphy: Before Katy was killed and you became the captain, had you acted as her second-in-command, even unofficially?

Jennifer Adams: She respected my opinion.

Detective Murphy: People probably saw that, which is probably why you were made captain so quickly. Did the two of you talk about personal issues?

Jennifer Adams: I wouldn't say that. We weren't friends or anything.

Detective Murphy: I thought you were the best of friends. Isn't that what you told us?

Jennifer Adams: Whatever. We weren't that kind of friends.

Detective Murphy: So she wouldn't have confided in you?

Jennifer Adams: Um, no.

Detective Armstrong: What's it been like working with Ms. Puskus now that you're captain?

Jennifer Adams: Great. She's a wonderful coach.

Detective Armstrong: She must advise you since you're still so new to the job, tell you how Katy would have handled things?

Jennifer Adams: Not at all. In fact, she said I've been doing a great job as captain, especially under these trying circumstances. She said I'll take the team all the way.

Detective Murphy: I just had a thought. Maybe Katy wasn't killed because she was Katy. Maybe she was killed because she was the cheerleading captain. Now that you're captain, have you received any threats?

Jennifer Adams: No. Of course not. Why would anyone want to threaten me?

Detective Murphy: If you do, don't keep them to yourself. Come to us right away if anything unusual happens.

Jennifer Adams: You don't really think I'm in danger, do you?

Detective Murphy: Until we catch whoever killed Katy, we don't know what else he or she might do. Keep your eyes and ears open.

Jennifer Adams: You're freaking me out.

Detective Armstrong: We don't mean to do that, Jennifer, but I'm sure you understand our concern. You'd probably be doing yourself a favor if you thought long and hard about who might have killed Katy.

Jennifer Adams: It's not like I know, and I'm just not telling you.

Detective Armstrong: That's nice to hear, and I hope it's true. If you remember anything that might help us find Katy's killer, you let us know, okay?


Jennifer Adams: I will. Can I go now? You're freaking me out.

Detective Armstrong: You can go. And you take good care, okay?

Jennifer Adams: Oh my god.

Interview ended – 5:38 p.m.

Comments (0)

There are no comments posted here yet
Tell your friends about Crime Scene

Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates


Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries:

For technical assistance:

Go to top