Friday, March 16, 2012 - 2:54 p.m.

Carol Edgar is a teacher at Oxford Middle School. The interview was conducted at the Oxford Middle School and was recorded on a portable tape recorder with the witness's knowledge and consent.


  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Carol Edgar

Detective Murphy: For the record, could you please state your name and address?

Carol Edgar: My name is Carol Edgar, and I live at in Oxford at 117 Deer Run.

Detective Armstrong: Some day, huh?

Carol Edgar: Kids always find a way to surprise you.

Detective Murphy: What happened exactly?

Carol Edgar: I saw a bunch of students on the playground, crowded around something. I thought it could be another dead bird. When I approached, I saw RJ stuff something into his backpack.

Detective Armstrong: What did you do?

Carol Edgar: I asked him what he had, and he said, "Nothing." So I asked him to empty his backpack.

Detective Armstrong: And?

Carol Edgar: To be honest, I half expected him to pull out a gun.

Detective Armstrong: Had he ever given you any indication he might have access to firearms?

Carol Edgar: No, but he fits the profile we hear so much about. He's a loner, very angry. I can't even imagine what he went through with Katrina, the things he might have witnessed. I just wouldn't be surprised if he showed up one day at school with a gun.

Detective Murphy: Do you know whether there are guns in the Brandt house?

Carol Edgar: He's never mentioned guns, one way or another.

Detective Armstrong: So you asked him to empty his backpack.

Carol Edgar: RJ pulled out what looks like a human skull. I was so shocked that I never did ask him to finish emptying the backpack. He might actually have been carrying a gun.

Detective Murphy: What did RJ say?

Carol Edgar: He said he found it when he was digging in his yard.

Detective Armstrong: Do you believe him?

Carol Edgar: Do I believe him? I'm not sure. I haven't caught him in a lie, so I haven't learned how to recognize when he tells one. His is a tough face to read.

Detective Murphy: Officer Squire said RJ told you it was a little girl's skull. Is that correct?

Carol Edgar: That's what he said.

Detective Murphy: Why do you think he said that?

Carol Edgar: I don't know. Maybe he thought it sounded more cool. He's 12.

Detective Armstrong: You didn't believe him?

Carol Edgar: How could he know whose skull it is, if it even is a real skull and not some stupid prank?

Detective Murphy: What's RJ like as a student?

Carol Edgar: He's not working to his full potential. I know that. Maybe we're making a mistake, coddling him. But that's the word that came down.

Detective Armstrong: Do you think it's a mistake?

Carol Edgar: I think the boy needs something to focus his energies. Schoolwork could provide that. I get these papers from him, half blank, the white space filled with drawings of wrestlers. I don't know if he just goes home and plunks down in front of the television, but if his teachers aren't going to push him, who will?

Detective Murphy: Have you met with his parents?

Carol Edgar: They come to parent conferences for their allotted five minutes. But, really, how much can you accomplish in five minutes?

Detective Armstrong: You're a teacher who has been dealing with parents in five-minute chunks for years. I bet you can accomplish quite a bit.

Carol Edgar: I don't think his home environment is optimal.

Detective Armstrong: In what ways?

Carol Edgar: Am I free to speak my mind?

Detective Armstrong: Certainly.

Carol Edgar: What about this tape recorder? Who else is going to hear this interview?

Detective Armstrong: That depends.

Carol Edgar: Enough said. His family experienced a horrible tragedy. RJ was very young. Some people come out the other side of something like that as better people. Some don't.

Detective Murphy: Thanks for your time.

Carol Edgar: You're welcome.

Interview ends: 3:08 p.m.

People in this conversation

Comments (2)

  1. Kimbers_case

While it is interesting that he said it was a little girl's skull and it was found to belong to a female, there was a 50% chance of that happening whether he knew anything or not. I look forward to seeing more evidence in this case.

Your account does not have privileges to view attachments in the comment
  1. Tara

Now what tragedy did his family experience? Could the skull have been a family member?

Your account does not have privileges to view attachments in the comment
There are no comments posted here yet


Crime Scene
3440 N 16th St, Suite #4
Phoenix, AZ 85016
Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280


Find us on Google+

Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates

Go to top
JSN Boot template designed by JoomlaShine.com