Michelle went to the station to answer some more of the detectives' questions

Tuesday, October 16, 2018 – 3:05 p.m.

Michelle Prescott was Kristi Waterson's cousin and roommate.

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy re-interviewed her at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department. Ms. Prescott's attorney, Slade Chesterson III, Esq. was also present


  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Michelle Prescott
  • Slade Chesterson III

Detective Murphy: Thank you for seeing us, Ms. Prescott. Would you state your name and address again for the record?

Michelle Prescott: Michelle Prescott, 588 Hathorn Road, Apartment 232.

Detective Murphy: Thank you. As you know, we're continuing to investigate Kristi's murder and—

Michelle Prescott: I know. I've read about it in the papers, and I find it disturbing.

Detective Murphy: How so?

Michelle Prescott: You arrested Hunter Nelson without having all the facts. I mean, it seems like you've made a terrible mistake, ruined his reputation, and for what? It was hasty and wrongheaded if you'll forgive me for saying so.

Detective Armstrong: You're awfully worried about this reputation thing.

Michelle Prescott: Pardon?

Detective Armstrong: Mr. Nelson was a viable suspect at the time, and yet all you can talk about is his reputation.

Michelle Prescott: It's essential. Hunter seems to be a respectable young man, and the higher you start, the farther you have to fall. We've discussed this before. It's important to be protective.

Detective Armstrong: Like you.

Michelle Prescott: What do you mean?

Detective Armstrong: Well, before, you mentioned how it's important to think of the consequences of your actions.

Michelle Prescott: Well, of course. I only associate with people who share the same interests and attitudes, who appreciate quality. Part of that is maintaining quality within myself. By that I mean it's important to uphold high standards.

Detective Armstrong: And Kristi didn't really live up to your standards, did she?

Michelle Prescott: Pardon?

Detective Armstrong: Well, earlier you criticized your cousin for being careless, reckless. Maybe you were worried she would rub off on you. A stain on your quality, as it were.

Michelle Prescott: Don't be ridiculous. We've discussed this already, and I refuse to speak of it further. It's insulting to the love I felt — and still feel — for Kristi for you to be accusing me of such awful things.

Detective Armstrong: Or maybe your boyfriend got a little too close to Kristi for comfort.

Michelle Prescott: No, absolutely not. You're being offensive. Slade, do something, please.

Slade Chesterson: Detectives, this is getting tiresome.

Detective Murphy: Our problem is this. Rob LaRouche can vouch for your whereabouts the night Kristi died, but otherwise, it's hard to really pin down what you were doing.

Michelle Prescott: Rob is a completely upstanding person. I don't understand why his word isn't considered adequate. I'm telling the truth, and he can attest to that.

Detective Armstrong: He may be completely upstanding, but apparently he can't tell time. Why would he say you showed up at an entirely different hour for your date?

Michelle Prescott: I have no idea. I can't control his inaccuracies. All I know is that I went to his house at 7:00 p.m. We went for a drive, stopped for gas, got back to the apartment around 8:30 and watched a movie. We ordered some food. I'm afraid I didn't record the minutiae of the evening beyond that, but surely someone saw us throughout the evening, the delivery driver or something. Aren't I right, Slade?

Detective Armstrong: Being spotted by a delivery guy isn't the same as being home all evening.

Detective Murphy: And earlier you said you didn't get to Mr. LaRouche's place until 8:30 to begin with. You can see why we're confused.

Michelle Prescott: It was 7:00 p.m. I swear it.

Detective Armstrong: Are you sure about that? Or maybe it was a little later because during that hour—

Michelle Prescott: This is so upsetting. I wish you would stop.

Slade Chesterson: Do you have a point?

Detective Armstrong: Or perhaps both you and Rob had a hand in Kristi's death.

Michelle Prescott: No.

Detective Murphy: Michelle, did you kill Kristi?

Michelle Prescott: Please. How many times do I need to say it? Of course, I didn't.

Detective Murphy: Who do you think did it then?

Michelle Prescott: I don't know. I haven't the slightest idea. I mean, it couldn't possibly be anyone I know.

Detective Armstrong: But it could have been someone Kristi knew.

Michelle Prescott: I don't know. Maybe one of her boyfriends, but I can't believe it. I mean, I can't believe she would put herself at that kind of risk. Please. I told you already I refused to be a party to that aspect of her life. I didn't want to be drawn into association with people like that. She had an illness, a wound that needed to be healed. It's so upsetting to think of.

Detective Murphy: Why would anyone want to hurt Kristi like that?

Michelle Prescott: I've told you. I don't know. I mean, I've gone over it so many times, and I can't think of any reason. It's completely senseless to me.

Detective Murphy: How do you think someone might have committed this murder?

Michelle Prescott: I can't imagine it.

Detective Armstrong: What would you say if later you were proven guilty of killing her?

Michelle Prescott: How? I didn't— it's impossible.

Detective Murphy: Well, would there be any reason for someone to have spotted you at The Turn that evening?

Michelle Prescott: Absolutely not. Please, Slade, this is too upsetting.

Slade Chesterson: Detectives, you've had your fun. You're going too far.

Detective Armstrong: We'll be the judge of that.

Michelle Prescott: No. I refuse to discuss this any further. It's so hurtful what you're saying, I can't stand it. I don't have to tolerate this, do I? I don't have to stay here?

Slade Chesterson: Let's go.

Detective Armstrong: Be our guest. Just don't go far.

Interview ended – 3:33 p.m.

Comments (0)

There are no comments posted here yet
Tell your friends about Crime Scene


Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates


Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries: store@crimescene.com

For technical assistance: support@crimescene.com

Go to top