What did the bartender see the night Andrea died?

Wednesday, January 11, 2017 – 3:00 p.m.

Will Sands is a longtime bartender at The Roadhouse Bar & Grill, where Gretchen Doyle and Andrea Stover met the night Andrea died.

Detectives Armstrong and Murphy interviewed him at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department.


  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Will Sands

Detective Armstrong: Good to see you, Will. Thanks for stopping by this afternoon.

Will Sands: You know me. Always happy to help.

Detective Murphy: It's been a while. Do you still know the drill?

Will Sands: Oh yeah. Will Sands, 1002 College Hill.

Detective Armstrong: You heard what happened to Andrea Stover?

Will Sands: Hard not to. Everybody's talking about it. She came in the night it happened, you know. She was a nice lady. Real shame what happened to her.

Detective Murphy: Did she come in alone that night?

Will Sands: Nah, she came in with her friend, Gretchen.

Detective Murphy: You know Gretchen too?

Will Sands: She comes in from time to time, enough for me to know her drink, not enough to be on a last name basis.

Detective Murphy: How often did Andrea come in?

Will Sands: Maybe once a week the last month or so.

Detective Murphy: Did she come in alone or with someone?

Will Sands: She came in with Gretchen a few times. Maybe once by herself but she didn't stay long.

Detective Murphy: Does Gretchen usually come in on her own or with friends?

Will Sands: She comes in alone a fair amount. She strikes me as the quiet type, you know, not afraid to spend an evening on her own. Otherwise, she came in with Andrea a few times like I said.

Detective Murphy: Does Gretchen ever come in with anyone else?

Will Sands: Could be. Nobody that stands out.

Detective Murphy: Did she ever mention any of her friends to you?

Will Sands: No, she's never been much for talking about herself that I know of. She always asks about me, how I'm doing, things like that, but she's not one for sharing her woes across the bar.

Detective Murphy: Gretchen has woes?

Will Sands: Everyone has woes, Sam. Besides bartenders, no one knows that better than you folks.

Detective Murphy: Truer words…

Detective Armstrong: Gretchen ever say anything to you about her love life?

Will Sands: Not really.

Detective Armstrong: Not really?

Will Sands: Well, come to think of it, she did mention a few times about her friend Andrea coming back to town. She was real excited about it. The way she talked, I thought maybe there was a little something between them.

Detective Armstrong: But?

Will Sands: But once I saw them together, I didn't think so anymore. Don't get me wrong. There was real affection between those two. Anyone could see that. But I didn't get a relationship vibe off of them. You know what I mean.

Detective Armstrong: You ever run across this woman? Her name is Ursula.

Will Sands: I don't recognize her from the photo. Maybe if I saw her in person. She got something to do with Gretchen and Andrea?

Detective Murphy: Tell us about that night Gretchen and Andrea were at The Roadhouse.

Will Sands: Nothing special I can think of. They came in together and sat at their usual table. I brought them G and Ts. They were there for a couple of hours. I let them stay while I was closing up.

Detective Armstrong: Did you notice anything unusual about them that evening? Did either of them seem upset or emotional?

Will Sands: Not really. Andrea seemed a little tired, a little beat down if you know what I mean. But they were just talking. Actually, Gretchen was listening a lot, and Andrea was talking. I guess every once in a while Gretchen would put her hand on Andrea's arm like she was encouraging her or something. Nothing out of the ordinary.

Detective Armstrong: Did you hear what they were talking about?

Will Sands: No.

Detective Armstrong: Nothing?

Will Sands: You know me. I give my customers their space. Unless someone's sitting at the bar in the mood to chat, I pretty much get their orders and leave them alone.

Detective Armstrong: How much did they drink?

Will Sands: Two G and Ts each. Gretchen had some water. Andrea asked me for a bitters and soda.

Detective Armstrong: With a gin and tonic?

Will Sands: Hey, I don't judge. People have different tastes. Some folks like a bitters at the end of the night.

Detective Armstrong: She seem like she was having stomach problems?

Will Sands: You know, you could be right about that. I told you she didn't look 100%.

Detective Murphy: What happened at the end of the night? The three of you leave together?

Will Sands: Actually, no. I was still closing up shop when they left. Gretchen thanked me for letting them stay a little longer. Then they headed to the door.

Detective Murphy: You let them go out alone?

Will Sands: Now, you know ol' Will better than that. I walked them out to their cars.

Detective Murphy: What time was that?

Will Sands: After midnight. Maybe 12:15, 12:20.

Detective Murphy: Did you happen to see where they were headed?

Will Sands: No. I made sure they got in their cars, and then I went back inside to finish up.

Detective Murphy: Did you see any other cars or people around?

Will Sands: None that I recognized.

Detective Armstrong: What do you mean by that?

Will Sands: There was a green sedan on the far side of the lot that I didn't know.

Detective Armstrong: You get the make and model? Maybe a license plate?

Will Sands: Sorry. I didn't look too close right then. I figured if it was still there when I went to leave, I'd make a note of those details. You all did a good job cleaning up our parking lot back when, but I keep an eye out to make sure no funny business starts up again.

Detective Armstrong: What else did you notice about it? Old or new? Foreign or domestic?

Will Sands: I'd say … not more than ten years old, but whether it was American or not, I couldn't tell you. Cars like that all look pretty much the same these days, it seems like.

Detective Murphy: When you left, was it still there?

Will Sands: Nope. I saw it drive out right after Gretchen and Andrea.

Detective Murphy: Did you see which way they went?

Will Sands: I believe Gretchen went west on Jackson, and Andrea and the green car went east.

Detective Armstrong: Have you seen that car since?

Will Sands: Not that I can recall, but I haven't been looking for it either.

Detective Murphy: Were you the last person to leave for the night?

Will Sands: Yeah. I finished closing up, and I left maybe 20 minutes later out the back.

Detective Armstrong: Have you seen Gretchen since that night?

Will Sands: No, but that's no surprise. I bet Gretchen is real cut up over all this.

Detective Armstrong: Anything else you can think of that might help us out?

Will Sands: Not that I know of. I sure hope you all have some other leads and aren't counting on ol' Will to break the case for you.

Detective Armstrong: You've helped us more than you know, Will. Don't you worry about it.

Detective Murphy: If you think of anything, give us a call.

Will Sands: Will do. You two come on in for lunch this week, and I'll fix you up. It's been too long, and it'd do you good to take a break from all this mess and have a good meal.

Interview ended 3:38 p.m.

People in this conversation

Comments (1)

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Good old Will Sands. Always got the info.

There are no comments posted here yet
Tell your friends about Crime Scene


Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates


Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries: store@crimescene.com

For technical assistance: support@crimescene.com

Go to top