Even in Santa's Toy Shoppe, there can be tension in the workplace. When Elf Caroline got the job that Elf Nancy wanted, was it hearty congratulations and good cheer all around?

Or was all that sweetness tinged with a pinch of something bitter?

With Caroline now dead, what does Nancy have to say?

Examine the evidence, and share your thoughts in the comments.

Tip: Want to catch up on what's happened so far in the Deck the Elf! case? Check out the Case Recap.

Want to see all the latest case documents as soon as they become available? Subscribe now.