Detectives Armstrong and Murphy brought in the Brandt family in hopes of finally resolving this case.

Click the tabs below from left to right to view all three interviews in the order they were conducted.

{jatabs type="content" position="top" heightTabs="180" mouseType="click" animType="animMoveHor"}




[tab title="RJ Brandt"]

RJ Brandt

Thursday, May 3, 2012 - 10:09 a.m.

Following the search of the Brandt residence, the detectives re-interviewed RJ Brandt. Because RJ is a minor, his father, Ronny Brandt, was also present. The interview was conducted at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department and was recorded with the witnesses' knowledge and consent.


  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • RJ Brandt
  • Ronny Brandt

Detective Murphy: Mr. Brandt, thanks for coming in again. Have a seat.

Ronny Brandt: Cut the niceties, Detective. What'd you pull my kid in here for?

Detective Armstrong: We wanted to talk to him about what we found in our search of your home.

Ronny Brandt: I found a mess. Ought to sue the darn county for an illegal search. Messing up my house, taking what belongs to me.

Detective Armstrong: We had a warrant. Everything was legal and proper. Now maybe you want to tell us about RJ's bedding.

Ronny Brandt: Talk to Heather. I don't know anything about that stuff.

Detective Murphy: Maybe you should learn. RJ, how do you explain the piece of fabric we found on a nail under your bed?

RJ Brandt: I don't know anything. Can I go now?

Detective Murphy: Not yet, son. Now think hard. Are you sure you don't want to tell us anything?

Ronny Brandt: RJ, keep quiet. The kid's room is always a mess.

Detective Armstrong: If you say so.. RJ, tell us about the kennel cage in the living room. We didn't find any dog. There was no dog food in the house.

Ronny Brandt: Darn dog ran off. We kept the cage. So?

Detective Murphy: Is that true, RJ? We found some of your bedding in that cage. And strands of brown hair.

Ronny Brandt: You know, this is a waste of time. That dirty dog got hair all over. Look, I've got stuff to do.

Detective Armstrong: Mr. Brandt, we think you know what was on that bed sheet. How are you going to explain the forensic evidence of your son's hair in the kennel? RJ, I think you should tell us what your father did.

RJ Brandt: What? No, he‒ he didn't do anything. I‒ I was goofing off. I went in there sometimes.

Detective Armstrong: RJ? Are you sure? Your parents didn't put you in that cage?

RJ Brandt: No, you got it wrong. He‒ he didn't do anything.

Ronny Brandt: Shut up, RJ. Detective, you got proof of this wild idea?

Detective Armstrong: The hairs are being tested for DNA as we speak. We also found bones in the cage. Chicken bones. One thing you never feed a dog. But then there's no evidence you ever had a dog.

Ronny Brandt: Like I said, stupid dog ran off. Look, I think you better quit harassing my family or I'm going to own this department. I'll slap such a huge lawsuit‒

Detective Murphy: You kept your son in there, didn't you? You punished him, treated him worse than a dog. You threw his food at him, made him grovel‒

Ronny Brandt: You listen. I did no such thing. That kid is always pushing my buttons, doing stupid things. I told him to stay out of that danged cage.

Detective Armstrong: What about the blood?

Ronny Brandt: What blood? OK, the dog didn't run away. It was sick. I saw blood before it died. You satisfied?

Detective Murphy: Better tell the truth, Mr. Brandt. We already know the blood is human, not canine. Tests will confirm a biological match. You wrapped your daughter's body in that sheet after you killed her, didn't you? Before you put her in the matching blanket you buried her in, right?

RJ Brandt: No, no. Dad‒

Ronny Brandt: Shut up, RJ. Got proof? Charge me. Otherwise me and my son are‒

Detective Murphy: Very well. Stand up. Mr. Ronny Brandt, you are under arrest for‒

RJ Brandt: No, no! Stop. He‒ he didn't do anything.

Ronny Brandt: RJ, shut up!

Detective Murphy: RJ, you have something to tell us?

RJ Brandt: He‒ he didn't do it.

Ronny Brandt: RJ, I said shut‒

RJ Brandt: It was me, you hear? It was an accident! I did it! He made me stay in the cage after that. Told me I was going to get them all in trouble. I was showing her some wrestling. I fell on her. She didn't move, so I wrapped her up in that sheet.

Detective Armstrong: Mr. Brandt, you have something to say?

Ronny Brandt: Kid, shut up. Not another word. Both of us ain't saying another darn word. Not until we get a lawyer.

Detective Armstrong: RJ? You'll feel better if you tell us what happened, get it out in the open. You've been keeping this secret for a long time, haven't you?

Ronny Brandt: RJ, I said shut it! He's underage. You can't make him talk. He's not saying another word until‒

RJ Brandt: I don't care! Gracie, she‒ she wasn't breathing. She looked all funny and blue. I didn't know what to do, so I wrapped her up. I tried to hide her under the bed, but she got stuck.

Detective Armstrong: So someone helped you move the body, isn't that right? Someone helped you cover it up?

Ronny Brandt: Not another word! This interview is over.

Interview ends: 10:33 a.m.

[/tab] [tab title="Ronny Brandt"]

Ronny BrandtThursday, May 3, 2012 - 10:40 a.m.

After terminating the detectives' interview with his son RJ, Ronny Brandt agreed to speak with Detectives Armstrong and Murphy on his own. The interview was conducted at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department and was recorded with the witness's knowledge and consent.


  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • Ronny Brandt

Detective Armstrong: Mr. Brandt, for the record, do you understand your rights?

Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I know.

Detective Armstrong: And for the record, you waived your right to have an attorney present at this time?

Ronny Brandt: Yeah, yeah. I got nothing to hide now. May as well get the whole thing off my chest. You said it would be easier on RJ this way.

Detective Murphy: RJ said he fell on Gracie and crushed her. Is that how you understand it?

Ronny Brandt: I told that kid a million times she was too little to have him wrestling with her. She loved to roughhouse with him though. And he was a good kid. Never meant her no harm. He really loved her. It was just a terrible accident. I guess.

Detective Murphy: But you didn't report it. You could have reported the accident. RJ is just a kid. How old was he when this happened? Nine? 10?

Ronny Brandt: And what if they didn't believe us? We went thith hlu could have repor- put h happensn'abbelicid't SIDSyou > uing anouse You ch. ly long hecie,hhooon'din thewhatas siif thith mes.cie,hhwe'di"> Ronny Bra Armstrong: And for tSerstandeJ ishhousd. Ho couwnd crushe

Detectivendt: And what find any d> e wnfell omeowaythis dog.aybe y d youasiera dog.ngs. Ilionhtprighduouse,'t

y-brt kno anything.hey dge‒ h though. > Detective Armstrong: And for tWhappe maave reed? Nine?> Ronny Brandt: And what d cagart mever do cagm talk?nd crushLeayinstrm ationbeen kmes.trm aget them talk.e‒

Detective Armstrongm>: But you das he mastanblood is >y-brong hd crus'p> Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I k he Detective Armstrongm>: But you dWh hai us whbette is >y-brot an the Brwithchoola kid crus'p> Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I k ho elsite repagm bp> Ronny Bra Armstrong: And for tJ. HondermTherchildrappei us w. Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I kIg. Ronny Bra Armstrongm>: But you dTat happ> Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I k he‒ havhbetteIg.

ei witnesse‒ hte ant to lifeust ang h! Thm thoughetim, hirty doglionittle toould h She lovedm to stay o times she was > Ronny Bra Armstrongm>: But you d havight d crushe, hih She RJ> Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I kelpe was tIg. en thil Ronoknapatawithau>: ow th RJ'ditalk.cie,d't /p> g timee rpl,d't / to > Ronny Bra Armstrong: And for tt the blood? Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I knt her Nine? 1d fkmesgeeveidn't p> Ronny Bra Armstrong: And for tow you understandespan> i">c beloa 12scripto stre for?aage in t I dim wobeloay old, su thr> Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I kHe siche ma?

tIg.c t I dkee input hhoom didnhe‒ she w' of rm abshe,ron> Ronny Bra Armstrongm>: But you dTey dge dog You o stl feHoom didnhe‒ > Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I kWat e dihe myou? Befohk?nARJ is ju want got stucyinstrm ationb Ronny Bra Armstrong: And for tif tyn kest son ewhaheet. Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I k havo anything.o hide n bloodidn't de understa havt. Thewhaheet.Thm ave reeven't yi dgeg ane d herlasshk?nARd crAvatary Bra Ae maisi thARJ is ju want got stucyin ane dant p> Ronny Brandt: Yeah, I kHe siche ma?repaoay ctivtbe es=yes,res Othmightrameowaed her/pb sI Yed is‒: >: Aibleniug was Dah, If****/em>: said aonnyponsibigh.J thihe Yoknapae maseacd her. xi. d act: Iazy she w' ou thr> Ronny Brandt<>Ronny Brandt: Yea she w': Yea>y-be siche/p>

Ronnother darn word. NAoWsI n blo himArmstrer undseacd her.omeowacted<, RJ. DIgot stuc‒ se bron Iazy'ditalkrn Roet youevhbeBrais js dcmmutty d,hhn thisd>

Ron57, Ronny Brandt agaptionnARJ is ju want got stucimee rpl darn deet.T>R>DetectiplahidJ'dith yeah.y

D> uth, Mive Murpith dtfule?anbent"> < susowthe wuof ti> < tried toinu ode her undathe we repaid aytI?thinuln, as well get thny Brandt< Yeah, I kelp thasmkIg.< yea ma? Rk harg henbewhe/he myony Bry o tirohk?nAssbeloe. he fell kilgo ele rpctive. Wh I k haref't r youaetalk.ensn o "w bro"rpit?anbeith him herdr undaid aytaegirnnywhere">nA rpcw Det, as well get thny Brandt< Yeah, I kelp fcornt"> < >ngs.kncordth ex Ros d Brae rpg Pt"> < > D> ou is d eduld > Ro/sp/ toI?thk hardworrted i> mstrow I k haw DettI?ay sI0:00:c {jatab Ybe>Ronny Brandt:h, I knor tt thbird an the Brwithchimee rpl darn deet.Ther terrherdr tn coun th RJ'ushed? 1d haviIt waou mov Murpuppdcmem>Rom>: And for ting Rs. Itective MStaiwaovhen W< > Detective Ar'm>: Nprit>nA r >ngs.kncordth ex And for : r >ngy d,wdem>pan the Brwithchny Brandt< Yeah, I kelp yoWst t know othe'ld1autrod. Nn W< mes she wasoe. Cra goil>Dek't /idnhiunty Stt waedn ke Bson in thsoft to ctivg henbew D> pared to>: tenyoingued tuof ti> dtpate rpnt g>brok idn't repor/heDetecttay Tenbeh< trrae rskjobd undwhnduasier o We wk/emof tido you Olk.eah, Iw ha jhyBra Armsiarticismackmyonyn ke Br Rtective> dtcttay m>: mov Murat dangser is="fc somwares O/em>movew was congt thetieutrod. NettteIviewmstras g> Dah, Iam>: W> <ectivea>Dah, I time, hav othe'ldhma?Ronny Brandt: Ron>Ronh, I kHe siras nhig.< rs> RondtDetectis d yoWthARJ > Jme I washot repou could hTnotherble">nA>Ro>ngs.iIt watisepe lov h net

id aytaetrag:c

Ronny Brandtw Dettsswoca>fcorandtytagormstrong>R>Devr >npid dogssbel anythiethrew hag.o hide shat d:uem>:hTnother k havo anythirp ye nowp> to de nowp>

cene.Ttere"artic62/ledbeont-uby in"right">sprecedh-t>Emas-prjoissprecedh-t>Emas-cyoWssprecedh-t>Emas-bg2">sprecedh-t>Emas-feat Nepsprecedh-t>Emas-cyoWssprecedh-t>Emas-bg1sshdiv>hat drem>e/eDndt-levelo sk"aric62/ledby in"right">sprecedh-t>Emas-feat Nepsprecedh-t>Emas-cyoWssprecedh-t>Emas-bg1sshdiv>Sves : if yo30-cayefreee/pmre"aric62/ledby in"right">sprecedh-t>Emas-feat Nepsprecedh-t>Emas-cyoWssprecedh-t>Emas-bg1sshdiv>C heclTp> ah,30hcayyt gk he et a Grablong rth "aric62/ledbull-right">sprecedh-t>Emas-0,mensprecedh-t>Emas-cyoWssprecedh-t>Emas-bg1sshppublishediv cla Ideas Sersmp;l S/ul>ont-ub>ont-ub>sprecedh-t>Emas-navsshpus Emas-pageak w hcarett>Emas-click=1ssby in>1ic62/lea>cr: #666666; font- font- font- font- font- font-nbofdndtn" ull-span9 orusermodul s3 -right"> =odul san12Artic3 tercol_inner"> l clabox-1 lass=odul an12Artictm< lass=odul an12Artic"jsn-maildndtldndtlh3-right"> Mbs" Pubus Biolblished">Biolblishedes-ms-o4 />BiolblishedunheclTndtBiolblisheding t-pare: 10>
  • -shmin 6previous-casUserre"> Rhmin Mic62/ledbettercase/pl>Biolblished hre-mhlunewsling t6previous-casVhre theeNewsling tMic62/ledbettercase/pl>Biolblishedopar">-and-oparoutrpolicy="/previous-cOpar"> gk Opartla-s">Biolblishedan12Actaus>
  • Ce/
    3440 N 16th St,/S/con #4
    Phoenix, AZ 85016
    Vojois(623) 565-8573
    ppublishe="arto:admin@as mg alt="RJ Brlry 3, 20Detectives A
    ppublishediv sclaplus.goospa> F/em>uof n Goospa+betters font- style="color: #666666; font- font- font- font- font- font-nbofdndtn" ull-span9 orposauser7dy-content" c4ss=" j3t" class="-contentolid-1 lass=odul an12Articlepull-right"> seserminatPing:" clacmgp: -10div scla Ideas class=""16-rpgves20Dop"rher" j="0"/>mg altPing:"artica-nbof/p cla/p clapublishedc924486051obrss/aut 605e incoerminatAlutCscrnFiga:" clacmgp: -10div scla Ideas class=""16-rpgves20Dop"rher" j="0"/>mg altAlutCscrnFiga:"artica-nbof/p cla/p clapublishedc924486051obrss/ascri href="/perminates-14735" clacmgp: -10div scla Ideas class=""16-rpgves20Dop"rher" j="0"/>mg altes-147358artica-nbof/p cla/p clapublishedc924486051obrss/susowth was recof="erminatases-14735" clacmgp: -10div scla Ideas class=""16-rpgves20Dop"rher" j="0"/>mg altases-147358artica-nbof/p claunde dbull-right">cr: #666666; font- font- font- font- font- font-ass="-contentolid-1 lass=odul an12Articlepull-right"> acy="arive_=odul solid-1s spanacy="arive_=odul _e"rmAcy="arive58481" class="-contenacy="arive_fullss=s spanacy="arive_fullss=_e"rmAcy="arive58481"ry 3, 20Detectives s tI>Seturn =de"rmAcy="arive58481" lh3>GengulekanempdEmasf n theeinvi>Clice Mur hre pr housempdEmasbetter thafont- ass="-contenacy="arive_e"rm>lclaoitle="Roonef / tof / tacyre">I spane / t_re">_e"rmAcy="arive58481"se/abclTe"r="user_re">_e"rmAcy="arive58481""-contenacy_requiredF / t">Naob /abcl- aass="articleacye / t_re">" clacn reespanuser_re">_e"rmAcy="arive58481""ry 3, 20ow"><:100px""rtyp 20Dete""-contencn reboxtrequired>=duser[re">]" valu>=deserminatNe">"/etimy in clauas gooitle="Roonef / tof / tacysa_pr/pspane / t_sa_pr_e"rmAcy="arive58481"se/abclTe"r="user_sa_pr_e"rmAcy="arive58481""-contenacy_requiredF / t">Es="sl /abcl- aass="articleacye / t_sa_pr/ clacn reespanuser_sa_pr_e"rmAcy="arive58481""ry 3, 20ow"><:100px""rtyp 20Dete""-contencn reboxtrequired>=duser[sa_pr]" valu>=deserminatEs="sl"/etimy in clauas gooitle="Roacy / clacn reetle="Rob

    bt> bt>-prjmary="typ 20=dS/ul>=dS/umit" onclice20Dry{ Seturn f"rm ng.he Grablonbocn reetle="Rob

    un bt> bt>-invirincoeyp 20b

    " valu>=dUn=dS/umit" onclice20Seturn nbouas gofdndtn" cn reeeyp 20hiddens=dajax" valu>=d0"/>n" cn reeeyp 20hiddens=dacy_sour35" valu>=d=odul _738-rp>n" cn reeeyp 20hiddens=dctrl" valu>=dn" cn reeeyp 20hiddens=dtask"fvalu>=d Grask"/>n" cn reeeyp 20hiddens=dred rwth"fvalu>=ddiv s%3A%2F%2F Ide666las n" cn reeeyp 20hiddens=dred rwthun=ddiv s%3A%2F%2F Ide666las n" cn reeeyp 20hiddens=dopaip>" valu>=dc92_acy="arivet/>n" cn reeeyp 20hiddens=dhiddenupids" valu>=d24t/>n" cn reeeyp 20hiddens=dacye"rmre">" valu>=de"rmAcy="arive58481-rp>n" cn reeeyp 20hiddens=dIontsp" valu>=d2826"/etimdndtn" /e"rms gofdndtn" fdndtn" ull-tle="Rocr: #666666; font- font- font- font- font- font- gofdndtn" fdndtn" fdndtn" fdndtn" ull-span9 orfoog t6tn" ull-span9 orfoog t=odul sdy-conten =odul san12Artic1 tercol_inner"> Alutan12 orld1apyn cla &1apy;eCe/, 1995-2016 vatad fonowrones. loith mi> uwsuitndtvar cb=func <'y 3, s to ';l.blish'/med a/plg_jchopaimize/e="e5sagz/1/0/05c93a1b08f7d8a6e2d79eb3e672c49d.css';var h=docu l}('head')[0];h. tow dC har(l);};var raf=requythAnimint||mozRequythAnimint||webkitRequythAnimint||msRequythAnimint;if(raf)raf(cb);mTherwin ow.addEngstL imy>