John Franklin

Friday, March 2, 2012 - 4:41 p.m.

John Franklin is a 65-year-old farmer, who owns land that Philip Fontaine wanted to buy. Detectives Armstrong and Murphy conducted the interview at the Franklin Farm residence on County Road 321. The interview was recorded on a portable tape recorder with the witness' knowledge and consent.


  • Detective T. Armstrong
  • Detective S. Murphy
  • John Franklin

Detective Murphy: For the record, could you please state your name and address?

John Franklin: My name is John Armstrong Franklin, and I live here on the Franklin Farm.

Detective Murphy: Do you have a legal mailing address?

John Franklin: Write Franklin Farm on the envelope, and it'll get to me.

Detective Armstrong: Thanks talking to us today, Mr. Franklin. You said you have some information?

John Franklin: I was pulled over by one of your fine young officers a couple days ago. Gave me a speeding ticket.

Detective Murphy: We're sorry to hear that, Mr. Franklin. It's a matter of public safety.

John Franklin: I ain't thought of nothing else since then. I'm not sure I even remember what it was I wanted to tell y'all. When you get to be my age, the mind doesn't always cooperate.

Detective Armstrong: Did you already pay the ticket?

John Franklin: I'll fight it in court. If I need to.

Detective Armstrong: I'm sure you don't need to worry about that right now.

John Franklin: Shame about Fontaine.

Detective Murphy: Philip Fontaine?

John Franklin: All of them really, but he's the one I meant.

Detective Murphy: What about him?

John Franklin: He's dead. You must've heard.

Detective Murphy: Yes.

John Franklin: He wanted to buy my farm, even though it's been in my family for generations. Wanted to tear everything down and put up who knows what. The man had no sense of history or tradition.

Detective Armstrong: You refused to sell?

John Franklin: I raised the asking price. Three times. Wasn't sure how high he'd go.

Detective Armstrong: Weren't you afraid the deal would fall through?

John Franklin: Fontaine was too hungry, like a gator that got a taste of his own tail. Besides, there was Coleman.

Detective Murphy: Coleman?

John Franklin: Bruno Coleman. He ain't hungry. He's bitter.

Detective Armstrong: What about Coleman?

John Franklin: That one's a gator who lost his tail. When you work the land, you learn a few things about life. You learn what nature knows, to seek out weakness.

Detective Murphy: So Fontaine was hungry and Coleman was bitter. So what?

John Franklin: Coleman paid me to be unreasonable. He didn't want Fontaine getting the land.

Detective Armstrong: You were playing them off each other.

John Franklin: I don't want to be yanking weeds when I'm 66.

Detective Murphy: Were you ever going to sell to Fontaine?

John Franklin: The situation was a little more complicated than just Coleman and Fontaine.

Detective Murphy: How do you mean?

John Franklin: A third party was also interested in the sale.

Detective Armstrong: Who?

John Franklin: About that speeding ticket. How do you get something like that out of the computer?

Detective Armstrong: You show up at court. Maybe you get lucky and the officer doesn't show up and the judge dismisses the case.

John Franklin: I have to go to court?

Detective Armstrong: No. You could just pay the ticket.

John Franklin: I got Fontaine shoveling money through my front door, Coleman shoveling it through my back door, and then someone else starts tapping at the window.

Detective Murphy: Go on.

John Franklin: Lady Fontaine is tired of Oxford, Mississippi. She wants to leave this backwater and see the world.

Detective Murphy: What did she want from you?

John Franklin: She asked me not to sell. If Fontaine got my farm and the project went ahead, they'd be trapped here for years. She couldn't wait that long to get out.

Detective Armstrong: Did she pay you too?

John Franklin: She did at that.

Detective Murphy: Do you know where she got the money to pay you?

John Franklin: Said she'd buy jewelry and then return it. Said Fontaine didn't notice that he never saw it again.

Detective Armstrong: Was there anybody who wasn't giving you money?

John Franklin: Neither of y'all have offered yet.

Detective Armstrong: Don't hold your breath. So one person was paying you to sell, and two were paying you not to. Did any of them know about the others?

John Franklin: Coleman and the missus knew about Fontaine, of course. Coleman wasn't too happy with how I was handling the situation. He wanted me to say no flat out, not string Fontaine along. But where's the money in that?

Detective Murphy: So when you were raising the asking price, Fontaine was paying you the difference up front?

John Franklin: As an advance against possible future considerations. I'm not going to live forever.

Detective Murphy: The day of his death, Philip Fontaine withdrew $15,000 from the bank. Did he bring that money to you that night, by any chance?

John Franklin: That would have been awkward. I was entertaining Mr. Coleman at the time.

Detective Armstrong: Bruno Coleman was here the night Philip Fontaine was killed?

John Franklin: He showed up with a bottle of bourbon and tried to convince me to flat out laugh in Fontaine's face. I think Coleman was afraid I might double-cross him.

Detective Murphy: When did he arrive?

John Franklin: A little after 5:00. And before you ask, he didn't leave until after midnight.

Detective Armstrong: Did he pay you to say this?

John Franklin: You think he might? I'll have to give him a call.

Detective Murphy: Was Mr. Coleman with you the entire time?

John Franklin: I had to leave the room a few times, what with my bladder, so Coleman wasn't in my sight every minute. But he didn't leave, if that's what you're asking.

Detective Armstrong: You drank together for seven hours? He could have told you what he wanted in just a few minutes and been on his way.

John Franklin: He tried that before. Now he was trying something different. I'm not going to refuse the man's bourbon.

Detective Murphy: Was Coleman interested in buying your farm?

John Franklin: Not that he ever said. He only wanted to cause trouble for Fontaine. Someone else did him one better.

Detective Armstrong: Any idea who?

John Franklin: No. I'm just a simple farmer. I leave the detecting to you professionals.

Detective Murphy: Thanks for taking the time to talk to us.

John Franklin: One hand washes the other.

Interview ends: 5:06 p.m.


Please login to comment

People in this conversation

  • Detective Murphy: Was Mr. Coleman with you the entire time?

    John Franklin: I had to leave the room a few times, what with my bladder, so Coleman wasn't in my sight every minute. But he didn't leave, if that's what you're asking.

    makes for interesting discovery

  • Remember Grant saying that there were no secrets in the house and both Grant and Ashley had arguments with Mr. Fontaine.
    Sounds like the arguments were a regular occurence. And I believe that both Ashley and Grant knew about the $15,000 and remember Ashley was the one tapping on the window of farmer Franklin not to sell his farm to Mr Fontaine. I don't doubt that they had both been threatened to be cut out of his WILL, and both knowing it to be a promise and not just an idle threat, and that Philip was deadly serious about it, and good reason for them both to want him dead. The other thing I fail to understand is, why wasn't all the phone calls of both house and cell phone records obtained.??????

  • Bruno Coleman , for my opinion is under a Reasonable suspicion , as well his linked connection and relations with Ashley Fontaine desire to escape Oxford, Mississippi.

Crime Scene
3440 N 16th St, Suite #4
Phoenix, AZ 85016
Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.


Find us on Google+

Get weekly updates on the investigation.

      Click to view previous updates

Go to top