Case Summary

updated September 27, 2004

In the early morning hours of August 15, 2004, independent filmmaker Corwin Fitz, who in Oxford was known to be somewhat eccentric, was found dead. His body was discovered in the half-filled bathtub of his bathroom in the lodge where his movie, Bacchanals' Destruction, was being filmed. He had sustained several gashes to his back, side and ear, believe to be from a machete found at the scene, as well as multiple gunshots to the back of his head. Considerable blood was observed in the master bathroom, with additional blood found in the master bedroom, and the autopsy report showed that Fitz died from the gunshot wounds to his head.

Also in the lodge at the time of his death were the members of the film's cast and crew: Katrina Brook, Brett Flamé, Macy Lamar, Johnny McPhail, Alsace Montenado, Billy Mummy, and David Woolworth. The victim allegedly had been holding these seven people hostage at the lodge, refusing to allow any of them to leave until the film was completed.

When Detectives Armstrong and Murphy arrived at the scene, Brett Flamé was repeatedly confessing to the murder, but given his highly agitated state, the detectives opted not to talk to him in depth at the scene, but instead had him and the other six cast/crew members transported to the Sheriff's Department for interviews. The interview with Brett Flamé was challenging and his claims were difficult to believe. He was the male lead in the victim's film and spoke about the various ways Fitz helped him get into character. Flamé initially confessed to the murder, but later refused to sign the confession.

The detectives next interviewed Katrina Brook, who found the body and was the victim's girlfriend. Brook provided information about events immediately surrounding the discovery of the body and about relationships on the set, including visits to the set by executive producer Chuckie King and a mysterious woman seeking a role in the film, Helen Troy.

Investigators followed up by interviewing Alsace Montenado, who initially claimed to have found the body and who called 911. Montenado described Fitz's aggressive nature with the actors and how he assisted with that. He also provided a different perspective on the relationship between Brook and Fitz.

Armstrong and Murphy next spoke with Billy Mummy, who played the villain in the film. Mummy told about the financial compensation the cast and crew were getting, the Brook-Fitz-Lamar love triangle, and the physical altercation he had with Fitz on the set, as well as other topics of interest.

The detectives talked to David Woolworth, who provided interesting information about the reasons the various cast members remained at the location, despite Fitz's harsh treatment of them. In the department's evidence archive, Armstrong and Murphy also found a video Woolworth released in 1999.

The investigators also interviewed Macy Lamar, who revealed some more about Fitz's activities prior to the time the cast and crew retreated to the lodge to film the movie.  They followed up that interview by talking to Johnny McPhail, who has provided valuable information in several previous investigations. McPhail gave his perspective on what went on at the lodge and on the personalities of the various people involved in the film. After learning that McPhail had met Fitz at Murff's bar in Oxford, investigators interviewed other Murff's patrons to see if any of them had met Fitz and knew anything about him.

The detectives contacted with the owner of the lodge where Bacchanals' Destruction was being filmed and interviewed Wilbur Pratt by phone at his home in Jackson.

The diagrams of the lodge's first floor and second floor show the locations where all the cast and crew members slept. Among the evidence collected from the lodge were a treatment of the script, the script itself, the victim's film journal, an odd note on the victim's bed, and a small arsenal of handguns. They also found various digital video tapes of the current film and previous projects, including an untitled video, one called Rebaptized, and one named The Balcony.

In the later pages of Fitz's journal, investigators found a letter from Robert Price, an associate of Fitz's currently residing in a Mississippi penitentiary. Armstrong and Murphy tracked him down and interviewed him at the prison. The first interview was unproductive, so the detectives returned to Parchman a short time later to re-interview Price. In his second interview, Price made wild claims that the investigators had no choice but to try to verify, regardless of how outrageous they seemed to be.

After finding an unsigned contract and an angry fax, both from the film's executive producer Chuckie King, among the victim's effects, Armstrong and Murphy interviewed King at his office. King, who has a unique personal history himself, provided information about his dealings with Fitz both before and during the shoot at the lodge.