Wednesday, July 30, 2014

Arrest in severed hand murder

Victim's in-laws voice support for accused killer

Exterior of the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department officeA mild-mannered nurse at Baptist Memorial Hospital was arrested yesterday evening for the July 4 killing of mechanic Andrew Fine, whose body was found buried in a field on Reagle Farm Road more than a week later.

Dudley Brinkman, 39, was arrested for murder at his home in Oxford. Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's investigators say Brinkman shot Fine in a pre-dawn attack at an abandoned farmhouse near the crime scene.

Brinkman and Cynthia Fine dated in high school but had not been in close contact recently, investigators say.

Cynthia Fine reported her husband missing after the holiday weekend ended and he failed to return home for work Monday morning, said Elizabeth Jones, information officer for the department.

A night of violence

Jones declined to specify the evidence against Brinkman but did say investigators are confident they know what happened the night Andrew Fine was murdered.

At a brief press conference announcing the arrest, assistant district attorney Calvin Dollarhide said Brinkman had allegedly been stalking Andrew and Cynthia Fine for an extended period including on the night of the murder.

That night, Dollarhide said, Brinkman allegedly followed the Fines to their Yocona house where he later shot Andrew Fine to death.

A source close to the investigation said Brinkman claims he was acting in defense of Cynthia Fine when he shot Andrew Fine, but Jones would not comment on whether detectives have found any evidence supporting that claim.

History of spousal abuse?

Although Andrew Fine was never cited for domestic abuse, his violent treatment of Cynthia Fine was well known, according to Robyn Campbell Dykman, Cynthia's sister.

Dykman has pledged to contribute to Brinkman's legal defense, saying the circumstances of the crime warrant a reduced charge.

"It's terrible Andy died — no one deserves that — but I can't say I want him back," she said.

Cynthia Fine declined to be interviewed, but released a one-sentence statement, saying, "I will always love my husband and believe he deserves the Lord's mercy and a place at His side in heaven."

An unlikely killer

Dudley Brinkman, now behind bars

Brinkman has no prior criminal record, and colleagues at the hospital reacted in shock to the news of his arrest, describing him as competent, gentle, and compassionate.

"He never talked much, but people would calm right down with him," said emergency room nursing supervisor Annette Cleary, who worked with Brinkman. "Being in the cardiac unit can be painful and stressful for the patients and their families, but he had a way of soothing them."

A call to the residence where Brinkman lives with his mother was answered by a man who identified himself as Reverend Gideon Horner of Trinity Church. Rev. Horner said Mrs. Brinkman was too distraught to speak to anyone and asked for privacy and prayers in this difficult time.

The district attorney's office has not determined whether to seek the death penalty in the case and refused to speculate on the possibility of a plea bargain or the credibility of the alleged mitigating circumstances.

A preliminary hearing is set for August 4, 2014.

By Kemper Jones at 9:15 PM

People in this conversation

Comments (2)

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

This is what I am making of the situation regarding Andy's murder.
Here was Dudley 39 years old, and had been a victim at the hands of Andy "the bully" for a large portion of his life.
He's a son every mother would be proud of. But he is a...

This is what I am making of the situation regarding Andy's murder.
Here was Dudley 39 years old, and had been a victim at the hands of Andy "the bully" for a large portion of his life.
He's a son every mother would be proud of. But he is a soft, kind, gentle and caring soul.
I believe all the taunts that he has been subjected to from Andy, for many long years had left him scarred.
Then knowing what his long time family friend Cindy has also been subjected to, by the brute of a man that she was married to, I believe is what had tipped him over the edge.
Dudley knew about Andy dragging Cindy out of their house late at night to the farm house. I can understand why Dudley would stake out their house late at night, knowing all of the information he knew regarding Andy. Wanting to see first hand what Cindy was being subjected to by Andy. And after he had eaten, he must have gone back to watch their house, when he did witness Andy dragging Cindy out.
When it goes to Court, they will need to allow at least 6 months for all the good character references, of those who are called to testify regarding Dudleys character.

Read More
  Di.
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Omg How ...could he be arrested. They bettter be looking at the evidence again. Because if he gonna go down he better bring the rest of the others down with him. Like I said I believe almost everybody interviewed at the police station was in...

Omg How ...could he be arrested. They bettter be looking at the evidence again. Because if he gonna go down he better bring the rest of the others down with him. Like I said I believe almost everybody interviewed at the police station was in connection of killling Andy. Because I feel they lured Andy to the farm, and they killled in in a group effort to take him out, together.

Read More
  G Holliway
There are no comments posted here yet
Tell your friends about Crime Scene

Weekly Updates

Get weekly updates on the investigation.
      Click to view previous updates

Contact

Crime Scene
3602 N 16th St
Phoenix, AZ 85016

Voice (623) 565-8573
Fax (602)-274-7280

For Crime Scene Store inquiries: store@crimescene.com

For technical assistance: support@crimescene.com

Go to top
box 300px

ForensiKit
by Crime Scene

a monthly subscription box

Explore the different techniques used in working a crime scene.

  • Learn about fingerprinting, collecting shoeprints, detecting blood, & more.
  • Makes a great gift for aspiring investigators, students, and other crime science buffs!

Each box (retail value $50+) comes with the same tools the pros use, directions, and learning activities.

Order now to get the January box

Learn More