Investigation Day 1
Late Sunday night, Julie Arbuckle found her neighbor Ambrose Garrett unresponsive in the community center near her house. She called 911, but it was too late, and Ambrose was pronounced dead at the scene.
The detectives talked to Julie at the scene about why she went looking for Ambrose in the first place.
Investigation Day 2
In the morning, investigators canvassed the residents near the Whitehall Community Center to find out if anyone saw or heard anything the night before.
While they were still looking for witnesses, the local media broke the news of Ambrose's death.
Investigation Day 3
Not long after she left, Mary sent the detectives a copy of her notes from the HOA meeting.
They also got the transcript of Julie's 911 call the night Ambrose died.
Investigation Day 4
Investigation Day 5
The next morning, the detectives pulled the report on the incident between Ambrose and Warren about a week and a half before Ambrose died.
That evening, Detectives Armstrong and Murphy had a few questions for Delilah herself after she got to work.
Investigation Day 6
In the morning, they spoke to Warren again about some of those fingerprints found at the scene.
Later on, they sat down with Mary again to find out what happened at the HOA meeting that wasn't in her notes.
Next, they visited Patrick to get him to clarify his relationship with Delilah and Ambrose.
Then they stopped by Julie's house to find out what light she could shed on recently discovered information.
After getting back to the sheriff's department, the detectives received additional findings from the crime lab just before their next interviewee arrived.
A few minutes later, Detectives Armstrong and Murphy talked to Jamie again, this time at the station in hopes of getting him to take the situation more seriously.
Investigation Day 7
The next morning, Delilah gave the detectives permission to search her residence for anything potentially relevant to her husband's death.
Investigation Day 8
After they'd finished at the Edwards residence, the detectives went to the McCahan home to get more information from David.
Investigation Day 9
First thing the next morning, investigators executed a search warrant at Julie's house.
Once the Arbuckle search was underway, Detectives Armstrong and Murphy stepped out briefly to ask Shannon a few more questions.
Later that afternoon, after they'd wrapped up at Julie's residence, the detectives met with the man Shannon claimed could confirm her story.
Investigation Day 10
Investigation Day 11
After sending all the evidence collected in the searches to the crime lab, the detectives decided to try one more time to find out if Chester saw anything at the community center the night Ambrose died.
Investigation Day 12
While waiting for the forensics, the detectives went over all the other evidence, witness statements, and alibis to narrow down the suspect pool.
Investigation Day 13
Investigation Day 14
The next afternoon, Detectives Armstrong and Murphy sat down with the suspect and their attorney.
Shortly afterward, the Oxford Weekly Planet's Crime Beat column posted their coverage of the arrest and the neighbors' reactions.