Friday February 22, 2013 - 3:00 p.m.
Carl Asher was Victor Jennings' friend and employee. Detectives Murphy and Parker re-interviewed him at the Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department. The interview was recorded with the witness's knowledge and consent.
- Detective S. Murphy
- Detective E. Parker
- Carl Asher
Detective Parker: Please state your name and address before we begin.
Carl Asher: Carlton Asher, 122 Caroline Circle, Oxford.
Detective Parker: Thank you for coming in. After the way our last meeting ended, we thought we might have a problem getting you to cooperate further.
Carl Asher: My bad. I tend to overreact from time to time.
Detective Murphy: Let's start fresh. Have you thought of anything that might help us in our investigation?
Carl Asher: Sure haven't.
Detective Parker: All right. Is there any member of the Jennings family that you think would want Victor dead?
Carl Asher: Why would you ask that? You think one of them killed him?
Detective Parker: I'm just interested in your impression of them.
Carl Asher: Sure you are. Brad thought Victor was the best thing since canned salmon. Little Ray couldn't fight his way out of a wet paper bag. And Margaret? Nah, he was her son, and no matter how much she disliked him, a part of her still loved him.
Detective Parker: So you don't think any of them could've killed him?
Carl Asher: Isn't that what I just said?
Detective Murphy: Please, Carl, let's keep it civil. We're just trying to find some answers.
Carl Asher: I don't have the answers. I don't know who killed him. It sure wasn't me!
Detective Parker: When did you last see Victor alive?
Carl Asher: I don't remember. A day or two before he died maybe?
Detective Murphy: Are you sure you didn't see him the day he died?
Carl Asher: I'm not sure. I don't remember. I might have, I guess.
Detective Parker: Someone told us you were there that day, having coffee in the room Victor was killed a few hours later. Remember now?
Carl Asher: Uh, yeah, I do. My days seem to run together sometimes. I think I was there that morning. Vic's lawyer was there also.
Detective Parker: Did you go in Victor's office that day?
Carl Asher: No.
Detective Parker: Are you sure? I know how your days seem to run together.
Carl Asher: Yeah. I'm sure.
Detective Parker: When was the last time you were in his office?
Carl Asher: Man, I don't know. Who cares?
Detective Murphy: How about this? We understand Victor kept a variety of knickknacks on the credenza in his office. Is that true?
Carl Asher: Are you talking about those dumbass executive toys?
Detective Murphy: Maybe. Do you remember what any of the toys were?
Carl Asher: I don't know. A Slinky, some pendulum thing, that goddamn applause button.
Detective Murphy: Anything else?
Carl Asher: Yeah, but that's all I remember. I don't play with toys.
Detective Murphy: Did you notice if any of those things were not on the credenza anymore the last time you were in his office?
Carl Asher: No.
Detective Murphy: No, they were all still there?
Carl Asher: No, I didn't notice.
Detective Parker: What time did you leave Victor's house on the 16th?
Carl Asher: Shit, I don't know the exact time. Like you said, my days run together. How in the hell could I give you a time?
Detective Parker: How about a general time, Carl? Can you do that?
Carl Asher: It was a few minutes after the lawyer got there. Vic needed privacy to talk to him and for what he was doing later.
Detective Murphy: What was he doing later?
Carl Asher: He was expecting company.
Detective Parker: Who?
Carl Asher: I believe it was a lady, more or less.
Detective Murphy: More or less?
Carl Asher: Some of his women were more ladylike than others.
Detective Murphy: Did he say anything specific about this company he was expecting?
Carl Asher: I wouldn't repeat what he said to a fine lady such as yourself.
Detective Murphy: That's very gallant of you. Did you by any chance have an accident while you were there that day? Bad paper cut or anything like that?
Carl Asher: Yeah, actually. I broke a coffee cup and cut myself picking up the pieces. So what?
Detective Murphy: There was a lot of blood in the kitchen. I just wanted to know if any of it might be yours.
Carl Asher: I don't think so.
Detective Parker: You've got some experience with… let's call it self-defense. Do you think the killer was injured when he or she killed Victor?
Carl Asher: Are you still trying to pin this on me? How many times do I have to tell you I didn't kill him?
Detective Parker: I don't know. Just something about you makes me want to keep asking.
Carl Asher: C'mon. What about that Kyle Colby kid? He came after Victor with a baseball bat. Maybe he came back with a knife.
Detective Murphy: Right now we're talking about you, not Kyle Colby.
Carl Asher: Don't forget that fancy pants Hawke either. Victor was going to expose his dirty little secret. Hawke certainly didn't want that.
Detective Parker: Interesting. What did you do after you left Victor's house on the 16th?
Carl Asher: I went to get something to eat. Then I ran a few errands, went home, and watched some TV.
Detective Murphy: What programs did you watch?
Carl Asher: I don't remember. No, wait. I was watching basketball, Georgia and Ole Miss. Good game. Went into overtime.
Detective Parker: One more time, Carl. Did you kill Victor Jennings?
Carl Asher: I told you no, bitch. How many times you do you want me to say it?
Detective Parker: That's about enough of you for today, Carl. Go. We'll be in touch.
Interview ends: 3:33 p.m.