| Mathis Case | News | Interviews | Evidence | Bios | Press | Photos | Home |
|
Viewer Discussion |

Evidence: Incriminating Letter from Will Mathis

The text of this note was entered into the court transcripts. Will Mathis denied writing the note and his handwriting did not match that in the note.

Mr. Shell Vines:

I will write you this statement, I want you to tell that I come to Kin's Sunday morning, and that I told you and Kin that Orlandus Lester had killed Hugh and John Montgomery and burned them and that I never had anything to do with it; that I was holding the lamp for them to go to bed, and I got into a fuss with Hugh about my pistol and the negro jumped in the door and shot them and that I told you all that the negro had slipped around my house trying to kill them unbeknowing to me, but he failed. I went in the yard and the negro made a signal to me but I thought he said shoot and I thought it was somebody trying to get to kill me and I shot at him and he then let himself be known and told his name. I told him he should not do it for they were just doing their duty as officers and made him go after some wood for me. I told you all that I was afraid they would put me in jail and I thought I would dodge until Court so if they put me in jail I wouldn't have to stay long. Tell that I never made any secret of it at all. That I said I would tell it if I was called. Tell that I showed you some pistols and you asked me what I was going to do with them. I told you that I am to give John Montgomerys pistol to his people and I aimed to keep the other two. I am going to have you and Kin summonsed to swear this for me. This was the first statement I made and if you all swear it they will have to take it. I am going to swear that Orlandus slipped off and got a gun and came back and tried to get to kill the men unbeknowing to me but failed. That some of us kept in his way and that I went out after some wood and he said "shoo" for me to come to him and I thought he said shoot and I shot at him thinking it was somebody aiming to kill me. He let hisself be known and told his name. I told him he should not do it and made him go after some wood and chop it up and I went in the house and in a few minutes the men went in to lay down and I carried the lamp in for them to see to go to bed and after they pulled their clothes off I saw my pistol and I told Hugh Montgomery he had told me a damn'd lie about my pistol and that I was going to have it and he said to me God damn you we will take you to Oxford tonight. The negro heard this and ran and shot them both before I knew he was in the house and we all left then and went to your Pa's and me and your Pa and the negro went back up there. There is not any use for me to tell you anything else that I am going to swear for you was not there. If you can swear the same that I have right and not get yourself in trouble I can come clear but I don't want you to tell anything to hurt yourself to save me. Don't let anybody know that I am going to try to beat it and that Lester is going to take it all on himself. If you all will do that I will come clear. The negro will tell he did it all and Cordie will tell the same and they won't have any witness against me. I am working the thing a damn sight finer that they think for. my lawyer says that this will clear me. I have never been sworn yet. Don't let anybody know anything about this. I want to surprise them.

Your friend,

Will Mathis,
Oxford, Mi

| Mathis Case | News | Interviews | Evidence | Bios | Press | Photos | Home |
|
Viewer Discussion |