Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff’s Department

Investigating Officer(s): Detective Terry Nelson, Detective David Anderson

Case Description: Kevin Gilmore Death Investigation

The YCSD followed up on the alibis given by the potential suspects in an attempt to verify their whereabouts on the evening and night of December 10, 1987, the last time Kevin Gilmore was seen alive.


Name of suspect Alibi Confirmed Not Confirmed
BROCK, Carly Was with Kevin Gilmore at 4:00 pm   X

Cannot be verified.
CROSBY, Nick With several teammates at the showing of Wall Street. 7:00 pm X

Verified by other members of the team.
FINNEGAN, Jason In the Kinard Hall recreation room watching TV. X

Verified by Richie Turner.
GILMORE, Don Playing cards at the Simpson household X

Verified by Mr. & Mrs. Simpson.
GILMORE, Judy Playing cards at the Simpson household X

Verified by Mr. & Mrs. Simpson.
ROBARDS, Tomas Home alone   X

Cannot be verified.
TURNER, Richie In the Kinard Hall recreation room shooting pool with Kevin Gilmore until 9:00 pm. X

Verified by Jason Finnegan.

Note: Five (5) of the seven (7) alibis did check out. However, all seven (7) suspects claim to have been sleeping overnight. Those claims can neither be confirmed nor disproved.

Please login to comment

People in this conversation

  • WOW....IF THEY WERE PLAYING CARDS AT THE SIMPSON HOME..WAS THE SIMPSON PRESENT,,,IF SO DID THE KNOW WHAT KIND OF GAMES WAS PLAYED...OK,,,,HOW MANY POOL GAMES WERE PLAY,,,WAS THERE ANY CAMERA TO VERIFIED THEY WERE PLAYONG POOL....WAS THER ANY FINGER PRINTS TAKE FROM THE POOL.STICK...SOMEONE NEEDS TO AS JASON FINNEGAN IF THERE WERE IN THE ROOM PLAYING POOL...WHAT DID KEVIN WEAR,,SHOES DID HE HAVE ANY JEWERLY..ETC..TOMAS WAS HOLE ALONE....can was he there all day..or did he leave and come back,what was he doing,did anyone check his phone records for incoming or out going he have a pet,,,most people leaves alone as a pet, what was jason watching on tv,,can he tell what happen what time it started and what time it end..who play in there,,,,,IF CARLY BROOK WAS WITH KEVIN WHAT WERE THEY DOIN,,,,AT THE TIME CARLY WAS WITH KEVIN AS HE CLAIM,,,WHAT DID KEVIN HAVE ON,,WERE WAS THE AT,,i think more quetion should be ask...this case i dont fill right...theres some unwanted things to be done.

Have you seen me?

Click to learn more

Have a question or a technical issue?

Let us know so we can help

Go to top