| Severed Hand Case | Interviews | Evidence | Biographies | Press |
| Solve the Case |
Crime Scene
 
For Members
 
Free Services

Here is what other viewers are saying about the current case...

 
Get exclusive case details by email. View sample. Email:

Privacy policy here

Evidence: Arrest Report - John Reagle
 

The following links are provided only to assist with navigation of this document and are not part of the report.

Offense(s) | Person 1 | Person 2 | Person 3

Evidence/Property | Reporting Officer's Narrative | Defendent's Remarks


INCIDENT / ARREST REPORT

Yoknapatawpha County Sheriff's Department
711 Jackson Avenue
Oxford, MS 38655

 ___ INCIDENT
     ___ Juvenile
     ___ Senior Citizen
     ___ Gang

 _X_ ARREST
     ___ Child Abuse
     ___ Domestic
     _X_ Involved Alcohol

 CASE NUMBER:
  002167-14G-2003

 Date Reported:
     7/14/03

 Time Reported:
     10:04 p.m.

 OFFENSE:
  Dead bodies; disinterment for sale or wantonness

 STATUTE:
  97-29-19

     _X_ Committed
     ___ Attempted

 OFFENSE:
  Profanity or drunkenness in public place

 STATUTE:
  97-29-47

     _X_ Committed
     ___ Attempted

 OFFENSE:
 

 STATUTE:
 

     ___ Committed
     ___ Attempted

 Location of Offense (Exact address, include Room/Apt. No.)
  Duffy's Bar & Grill, 2201 Jackson Ave W, Oxford

 Date of Offense:
  7/14/03

 Time of Offense:
  10:30 p.m.

 Location of Arrest (Exact address, include Room/Apt. No.)
  Duffy's Bar & Grill, 2201 Jackson Ave W, Oxford

 Date of Arrest:
  7/14/03

 Time of Arrest:
  10:30 p.m.

 Arresting Officer:
  Kennon Winters

 Unit Number:
  216

 Assisting Officer:
  N/A

 Unit Number:
  N/A

Back to top

PERSON 1

 Type:
 Arrestee

 Category:
 Adult

 Foul Play Suspected
 Yes

 Name:
 Reagle, John

 Alias/Street Name/Nickname
 Johnny, Farmer Johnny

 Vic/Offender Relationship
 unknown

 Race
 White

 Height
 5' 8"

 Weight
 160

 Hair
 Brown

 Eyes
 Brown

 Sex
 Male

 Hat
 none

 Jacket/Coat
 none

 Shirt
T-shirt, white

 Pants
 Jeans, blue

 Skirt/Dress
 N/A

 Age
 43      ____ Estimated

 DOB
 6/6/60

 Social Security #
 XXX-XX-XXXX

 Scars/Marks/Tattoos
 none

 Injury Extent
 none

 Injury Description
 N/A

 Address
 522 CR 418, Oxford, MS 38655

 Res Phone 234-XXXX
 Bus Phone 234-XXXX

 Occupation
 Farmer

 Employer/School
 Self

 Employer Address
 522 CR 418, Oxford, MS 38655

Back to top

PERSON 2

 Type:
 Complainant

 Category:
 Business

 Foul Play Suspected
 No

 Name:
 Mulvaney, Patrick Michael

 Alias/Street Name/Nickname
 none

 Vic/Offender Relationship
 unknown

 Race
 White

 Height
 5' 11"

 Weight
 175

 Hair
 Red

 Eyes
 Green

 Sex
 Male

 Hat
 none

 Jacket/Coat
 none

 Shirt
 Polo shirt, red

 Pants
 Jeans, blue

 Skirt/Dress
 N/A

 Age
 25      ____ Estimated

 DOB
 5/18/78

 Social Security #
 XXX-XX-XXXX

 Scars/Marks/Tattoos
 none

 Injury Extent
 none

 Injury Description
 N/A

 Address
 1538 Jackson Ave E, Oxford, MS 38655

 Res Phone 281-XXXX
 Bus Phone 236-XXXX

 Occupation
 Bartender

 Employer/School
 Duffy's Bar & Grill

 Employer Address
 2201 Jackson Ave W, Oxford

Back to top

PERSON 3

 Type:
 Witness

 Category:
 Adult

 Foul Play Suspected
 No

 Name:
 Rodrigues, Elisa

 Alias/Street Name/Nickname
 none

 Vic/Offender Relationship
 unknown

 Race
 Hispanic

 Height
 5' 4"

 Weight
 130

 Hair
 Black

 Eyes
 Brown

 Sex
 Female

 Hat
 none

 Jacket/Coat
 none

 Shirt
 Polo shirt, white

 Pants
 Kahki

 Skirt/Dress
 N/A

 Age
 28      ____ Estimated

 DOB
 2/4/75

 Social Security #
 XXX-XX-XXXX

 Scars/Marks/Tattoos
 none

 Injury Extent
 none

 Injury Description
 N/A

 Address
 102 Combs St, Oxford, MS 38655

 Res Phone 232-XXXX
 Bus Phone 236-XXXX

 Occupation
 Bartender

 Employer/School
 Duffy's Bar & Grill

 Employer Address
 2201 Jackson Ave W, Oxford

Back to top

ITEMS OF EVIDENCE/PROPERTY RECOVERED

 (1)

 Type
     ___ Damaged
     ___ Lost
     ___ Recovered
     ___ Stolen
     _X_ Taken into Evidence

 Item Description

Plastic storage container, measuring approximately 9" x 5" x 4" and containing an object that appears to be a human hand

 (2)

 Type
     ___ Damaged
     ___ Lost
     ___ Recovered
     ___ Stolen
     ___ Taken into Evidence

 Item Description
 

 (3)

 Type
     ___ Damaged
     ___ Lost
     ___ Recovered
     ___ Stolen
     ___ Taken into Evidence

 Item Description
 

Back to top

 REPORTING OFFICER'S NARRATIVE (Brief narrative of the facts surrounding the offense and the arrest.)

R/O was dispatched to the scene at 10:04 p.m. in response to a 911 call reporting a man in possession of a human hand at Duffy's Bar & Grill. Upon arrival at 10:10 p.m., R/O entered the establishment and was met by complainant. Complainant said a female customer had notified him that an adult white male patron was in possession of a container he claimed contained a human hand and was displaying same to other patrons. The female customer pointed out subject to complainant. Complainant said he asked subject to show him the container and, after seeing it, decided to notify authorities. Complainant noted subject had been at the establishment for several hours and had consumed multiple alcoholic beverages. Complainant indicated the subject, who was seated at a booth near the street-facing windows.

R/O observed subject had in his possession a plastic storage container. R/O approached subject and requested that he accompany him outside the establishment. R/O also requested subject bring the container. Subject complied. On the sidewalk outside the establishment, R/O noted subject had a strong odor of alcohol on his breath and appeared to be intoxicated. R/O asked subject to identify the contents of the container. Subject said it was the hand of his former girlfriend, Lisa Holman. R/O requested permission to examine the container. Subject agreed and turned the container over to R/O. R/O conducted an external examination and determined the contents appeared to be a human hand, severed at the wrist. R/O opened the container to conduct an internal examination. The odor emanating from the container was strong and unpleasant. R/O replaced the lid on the container and terminated the examination. R/O advised subject of his rights and placed him under arrest. R/O transported subject to the Yoknapatawpha County Detention Center for processing.

Back to top

 DEFENDANT'S VERSION/REMARKS (What did the defendant say about the offense or his/her whereabouts at the time of offense?)

Prior to arrest, subject said the item in the plastic container was the hand of his ex-girlfriend, Lisa Holman. During transport to the jail subsequent to arrest, subject claimed it was just a joke and the item in the plastic container was really only a strange root he had found on his farm.

Subject made no further remarks regarding the offenses he is charged with during the time he was in R/O's presence and/or custody.

Back to top

 REPORTING OFFICER

 Kennon Winters

 DATE REPORTED

 7/14/03

 REPORTING OFFICER

 //Kennon Winters
 Signature

 216
 Unit Number

 7/14/03
 Date

 SUPERVISING OFFICER

 //Steven Spearman
 Signature

 446
 Unit Number

 7/14/03
 Date

Back to top

 

| Severed Hand Case | Interviews | Evidence | Biographies | Press |
| Solve the Case |